One of the more emotional — and consequential — issues families face is when to have that talk with Mom or Dad about the possibility of giving up their car keys.
For the driver, there’s the fear of losing their last vestige of independence and having to rely on family and friends to get around. For other family members, there’s anxiety every time their loved ones drive and concern for the safety of others on the road.
But despite the major role mobility plays in the lives of older people, a University of Michigan poll released last month found that only about half of families have a plan to deal with eroding driving skills.
Researchers for the university’s Institute of Healthcare Policy & Innovation and Transportation found that 62% of adults 65 and older said they have driven in the past six months and of those 81% said they are confident in their driving ability right now, but only 43% are confident in their ability to drive for another five years.
Despite those concerns, 54% said they hadn’t discussed plans for what will happen when they can no longer drive.
“The freedom to drive where you want, when you want is a critical part of independent living for older adults, and when it’s diminished for any reason it can have profound effects,” researcher Renée St. Louis of UMTRI said in a news release. “With most of the Baby Boom generation now in their mid-60s and above, we have millions of older drivers who will need guidance and alternatives as their health begins to affect their ability to drive safely.”
That’s why the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation has an elaborate system in place to help drivers maintain their skills. It also has methods to identify and remove drivers who should no longer be on the road.
The goal is to take a proactive approach to address potential problems through continuing training before the situation reaches a point where a driver’s license is suspended, said Angelia Gillis, chief of PennDOT’s Driver Safety Division.
“It’s a very passionate and personal situation,” Ms. Gillis said about driving privileges. “It’s the last piece of independence people have. We want them to be able to drive as long as they can, as long as they are safe.”
Mandatory reporters
Under state law, doctors are required to report to the state if they think a patient might be losing the skills to continue driving safely. Those concerns, which also can be reported anonymously by family members or others, can trigger an immediate suspension if someone has had a stroke or seizure or require drivers with diminishing skills to visit one of 10 driving schools across the state for a skills assessment.
When the state receives a report about a particular driver, PennDOT sends that person a letter saying they have been referred to the department’s medical unit for a review of their health and skills. The driver never knows who filed the report.
In many cases, Ms. Gillis said, older drivers aren’t surprised about the referral.
“Most of the time — 90% of the time — they already are aware (of their problems driving)” she said. “The older drivers are more aware of their limitations.”
Notably, the University of Michigan poll showed 68% of those who have driven in the previous six months have avoided driving in some conditions. For example, 53% said they avoid driving in bad weather and 48% avoid night driving.
In addition, the state randomly sends notices every month to 1,900 drivers age 45 and older six months before their license expires telling them they have to take their driver’s exam again, including a medical exam and vision test. If there are no issues, they can continue to drive, but if there are issues they must be addressed before the license can be renewed.
How many drivers lose their license every year? Through Dec. 1 this year, 5,667 drivers 45 and older have had their driving privileges taken away, compared to 6,037 for all of 2024. That’s everyone who lost their license for medical reasons or failed the test. Another 362 have voluntarily given up their licenses this year, compared to 396 in 2024.
Ms. Gillis noted that some of those suspensions are temporary while a driver recovers from a medical condition or is on certain medication, and others can be permanent. The state doesn’t track whether a driver is able to reacquire the license.
In an effort to keep that from happening, the state offers a 5% discount on auto insurance for drivers 55 and older who take a refresher class that includes tips older drivers can use so they can continue driving safely. Those tips include things like staying focused on the road rather than looking around the car or at the side of the road because it can take an older driver’s eyes as long as two second to refocus if they look away.
AAA and AARP are certified by the state to run those classes, which consist of eight classroom hours the first time a driver attends, then four hours as a refresher every three years.
J.J. Miller, who conducts classes in the Pittsburgh area for AAA, said her students include some drivers looking for the insurance discount, some sent by doctors for a refresher, and some who just realize they aren’t as sharp as they used to be.
Ms. Miller said the agency has identified the five biggest challenges for older drivers: unprotected left turns (also known as the Pittsburgh left); merging; bearing right at a yield sign; turning left from a stop sign; and changing lanes.
In the $18 class, she gives them tips such as counting how long it takes to go a certain distance so they can gauge how much time they need to build up the speed for a safe merge or turn. They also learn that they can avoid a left turn by making several right turns to reach their destination.
In addition to the classroom program, AAA offers the CarFit program, in which officials review a driver’s vehicle and make recommendations on such items as seat location and setting mirrors. For drivers with mobility or access issues, the program offers swivel seats to make it easier to get in and out of a vehicle.
‘Delicate’ conversation
As president of Rogers Driving School in Shaler, Tim Rogers sees first-hand the “very delicate” situation older drivers can face. It’s such a sensitive area that when a doctor refers a patient to the school to test their driving skills, Mr. Rogers conducts all of the 90-minute evaluations himself.
“It’s a very stressful thing. Many of these people have been driving since they were 16,” said Mr. Rogers, who has had drivers cry because they know they shouldn’t be driving. “The way I look at it is that they may be losing their last bit of independence.
“But you also have to look at the safety aspect of it for them and the other people on the road.”
Mr. Rogers said that during the driving test he fills out an assessment form for the driver, then returns it to the doctor. He tells the driver up front that the decision won’t be made by him and he won’t share with them what he is reporting.
“We send the results to the doctor,” he said. “Either we say we have concerns or we don’t have concerns. It’s up to the doctor to tell the patient (if they can continue driving) and decide whether to release the report.”
Unfortunately, the experts say, there’s no magic age at which someone should quit driving. Some should lose their keys before they reach age 60 and others can still be safe into their early 90s.
“As we get older, we all have diminished capacities we have to deal with,” Mr. Rogers said. “It may not be an age thing. They may have always had bad driving habits and now they don’t have the skills to make up for them.”
Family conversations about driving skills often are difficult, said Ms. Miller, the AAA instructor. In some instances, police officers and PennDOT employees have anonymously reported to the state family members who rebuffed efforts to keep them from driving.
Ms. Miller recommended sitting down with a loved one and working out a plan for how others can help them meet their needs without taking away their independence.
“I would say talking with your family is the best way,” Ms. Miller said. “You shouldn’t be confrontational. Don’t argue. You should be calm and tell them you’re having this conversation for everybody’s safety.
“Not everyone wants to be a burden on their children, but everyone wants to be safe and not hurt someone else.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.