A group of Strip District business owners who are suing the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure will still have to pay a bond to temporarily prevent the city from reducing Penn Avenue to one lane between 22nd and 31st streets, per a court order Wednesday morning.

Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg lowered the Strip District Business Association’s bond amount to $39,749 — a sizable reduction from the $112,000 DOMI estimated that it would incur in damages if work suddenly stopped on the project, which began late last month.

But the Business Association’s attorney, John A. Daller, of New Castle, had requested the court to reduce the bond to a “nominal” amount on Oct. 3.

Mr. Daller said that when he asked DOMI for evidence to justify the original bond figure, he received 202 pages worth of citywide milling, paving and asphalt contracts that did not include penalties for delay by the city or even mention the Penn Avenue project.

Advertise with us

“It’s basically contracts that they have with three vendors to do all the paving in the city of Pittsburgh, and [it] doesn't say anything about this specific project,” he said. “They were disingenuous, to say the least.”

Mr. Daller emphasized that the business association was not opposed to milling and paving the road, just reconfiguring it to remove a lane of traffic in favor of a bike lane.

City Solicitor Krysia M. Kubiak and Associate Solicitor John F. Doherty filed a “Response in Opposition,” to Mr. Daller on Tuesday, arguing that the city had “little more than twenty (20) minutes to prepare” the $112,000 estimate after the business association’s request for emergency relief to stop the project on Sept. 29 and did not have enough time to calculate the “exact cost” for the milling, paving and asphalt contracts.

The two parties then discussed the issue on Sept. 29, according to the filing. DOMI claimed that the business association during the discussion did not clarify that it was only seeking to stop the reconfiguration of the travel lanes.

DOMI produced a new estimate that it would cost just under $40,000 to apply temporary “status quo” traffic markings while the lawsuit plays out because it has already completed the street resurfacing portion of the project.

Advertise with us

While the city offered to provide contracts backing up the projected cost, Mr. Daller said that the justification was “pretty vague” as-is.

“My clients aren’t traffic engineers — they don’t have proof of how much it’s [going to] take to put whatever markings on the street, at least on a temporary basis,” he said.

Wednesday’s hearing marked the latest battle in the ongoing fight between the city and business association over the “Penn Avenue Rightsizing” project, which was announced last spring. The business association is concerned that reducing Penn Avenue to one 15-foot-wide lane would snarl traffic, make it difficult for businesses to unload shipments, and violate the 2018 International Fire Code that the city adopted in 2020, which requires fire vehicle access roads to be at least 20 feet wide.

“We’re looking forward to the hearing, when some of these other issues can be addressed,” Mr. Daller said.

Should the lawsuit proceed, the evidentiary hearing will take place in the City-County Building in Downtown on Oct. 16.