The city’s controversial plan to permanently reduce Penn Avenue to one lane through the heart of the Strip District came to a halt Monday morning after a judge temporarily granted a group of local business owners’ request for an emergency injunction.

The city of Pittsburgh had planned to start construction on the project on Tuesday, despite objections from a group of local businesses who said the plan will create traffic nightmares and stop people from visiting the Strip.

The Strip District Business Association — which formed to oppose the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure’s effort to replace a lane of inbound traffic on Penn Avenue between 31st Street and 22nd Street with a bike lane and additional parking — had filed a lawsuit earlier this month in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court opposing DOMI’s plan on several counts, including that it would interfere with business operations.

The group also alleged the new, 15-foot-wide lane violates the 2018 International Fire Code that the city adopted in 2020, which mandates that fire vehicle access roads be at least 20 feet wide.

Advertise with us

In a ruling Monday, Judge Alan Hertzberg granted a preliminary injunction blocking DOMI’s plan — but it came with a significant financial hurdle for the business association.

The court asked the group to file a $112,000 bond or deposit $112,000 with the Department of Court Records in order for the injunction to take effect. This is done in cases where the court agrees to grant the injunction without notice and hearing to prevent an imminent and irreversible consequence, such as the start of construction.

The judge granted the injunction until an evidentiary hearing can be held at 9:30 a.m. on Oct. 16 in the City-County Building Downtown to determine whether it should be continued, dissolved or modified. DOMI could also attempt to dissolve the injunction before then by petitioning the court.

If at any point the court decides that the injunction was improperly granted, based on the representations of the Strip District Business Association, then the bond company would have to cover the damages to anyone injured by the petition and the plaintiffs would be liable to the bond company.

Judge Hertzberg denied the business association’s first lawsuit on Friday, writing that it needed a licensed Pennsylvania attorney to file in court instead of one of its members, Allegheny Coffee & Tea Exchange owner Daniel Nolan.

Advertise with us

John A. Daller of Daller Law Firm in New Castle refiled the lawsuit Sunday on the business association’s behalf. Mr. Daller said that the $112,000 bond is the city’s estimate of the cost of delaying construction, and he has requested an explanation of how it arrived at that figure.

“It’s very hard to understand how a delay in painting could lead to that type of damage if the road needs to be repaved anyway,” Mr. Daller said.

Mr. Daller added that since the Trump administration has halted funding for bike lane projects nationally and the city is in debt, the financial burden will fall to local taxpayers.

The Department of Mobility and Infrastructure had announced Friday that it would mill and pave the construction site during the evenings this week, beginning at 8 p.m. on Tuesday and through 8 a.m. on Saturday.

DOMI planned to install pavement markings and “vertical elements” like bump-outs and rubber speed humps next week. The agency estimated earlier this year that the project would take a matter of days to install in its entirety.

Advertise with us

Jim Coen, president of the business association and owner of Yinzers in the Burgh, said that DOMI’s announced construction timeline was “ridiculous” given the ongoing legal dispute. He maintained that City Council should have to approve such a change to a major road.

The business association had referred the matter to the council’s Public Safety and Wellness chair, Anthony Coghill, and received a statement from his chief of staff, G. Blake Plavchak, opposing the project that it later submitted to the court on Sept. 25.

Mr. Plavchak noted that the project is not in Mr. Coghill’s district — it’s in District 1 Councilman Bobby Wilson’s — but said Mr. Coghill had “very strong concerns” about the project after speaking to Bureau of Fire Chief Darryl E. Jones, whom he said does not endorse any project that violates the International Fire Code.

“To make the councilman’s position clear, if he did have a say in this project, he would be opposed to it owing to Chief Jones’ concerns as well as broad opposition in the Strip’s business community,” Mr. Plavchak wrote.

Mr. Coen’s safety concerns were blunt: “If you have a major fire, which we’ve had in the past month or two, people are going to die.”

Olga George, a city spokeswoman, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.