Few residents who were eligible to take part in the historic East Palestine, Ohio, train derailment settlement decided to withdraw from the agreement by the court-ordered deadline, new case filings show. Even fewer submitted objections.
In April, Norfolk Southern had agreed to pay $600 million to resolve claims for damages suffered by thousands of people after its freight train derailed near the Ohio-Pennsylvania border and led to a vent and burn of hazardous chemicals three days later.
In the days leading up to the July 1 deadline to opt out of the agreement or to submit objections, residents told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette about their confusion and concerns around the settlement terms. They worried about the legal implications for their families long term, as joining certain aspects of the suit would mean giving up some of their legal rights in the future.
Court documents now indicate that less than 1% of the estimated 190,887 households in the settlement class ultimately opted out. Of the estimated 1,929 households in East Palestine, 22, or 1.1% elected to opt out.
Adam Gomez, an attorney with Grant & Eisenhofer who was involved in the negotiations with Norfolk Southern, called those results “encouraging.”
“I think it's an indicator that the vast majority of the class, especially those nearest to the derailment, view the settlement as a good outcome and want to participate and want to receive the benefits,” Mr. Gomez said.
Read More
Although not everyone agreed, as 15 objections were submitted by residents by the July 1 deadline. A prominent theme that emerged was concerns with the timeline, as residents argued that they weren’t given enough time to make a fair, informed decision about opting out of the settlement.
Two of the objectors, who are represented by the same counsel, David Graham Insurance Law of Florida, asked to extend the court-ordered deadline by at least 60 days — or no earlier than Aug. 24.
One of those individuals was Joseph Sheely, East Palestine resident and pastor of Solid Rock Community Church in Salem, Ohio. Rev. Sheely said he and his wife live 2 miles away from the derailment site and have suffered numerous health issues since the accident, including heart and blood pressure problems. They have also struggled to sell and move out of their home, where they intended to stay the rest of their lives as retirees.
Rev. Sheely argued in his objection that this case involves a complex settlement where tens of thousands of class members, whose injuries vary by type and severity, will be receiving unknown amounts of settlement cash benefits based on an “undisclosed” formula. The notices sent out to everyone in the settlement class had listed criteria that will determine the payout amounts, like household size. But he said it doesn’t outline the allocation formula in detail, leaving residents with “incomplete” information for how the payments will actually get calculated.
“I personally think that the money that they're giving to these residents is a pittance,” Rev. Sheely said. “There's some people who are just willing to take whatever they can get.”
In a Monday filing, the legal counsel representing residents told the court that any further delays would hurt people who “need and deserve” timely compensation for their losses. Pushing off the deadline would mean residents wouldn’t see their money until next year, the attorneys contended, and that people have been aware about the settlement since April, giving them enough time to weigh their options.
Mr. Gomez said submitting this response is an “unusual” procedural step in cases like this, but it was important to address the deadline issue early on. The court will issue a ruling on whether to extend the opt-out deadline in the coming days or weeks, and then evaluate the other objections during a Sept. 25 hearing.
“The community should know whether or not that period will be extended,” Mr. Gomez said. “We don't believe it will be, but that's obviously within the court's discretion.”
Mr. Sheely’s objection had also noted that “new and substantial” evidence has and continues to be released about the derailment, including from the National Transportation Safety Board.
One revelation that concerned objectors like himself came during the NTSB’s recent board meeting, when chair Jennifer Homendy called out Norfolk Southern for repeatedly interfering with its investigation. Ms. Homendy said the railroad company attempted to sidestep investigators, pressure the board to use their testing results and other evidence, and withheld information.
“They wanted everybody to decide by July 1 if they were going to opt out of the settlement, but that doesn't even give people enough time to turn around, let alone think about what, what they just heard,” Rev. Sheely said.
Mr. Gomez said while “frustrating,” Norfolk Southern’s actions during the NTSB’s investigation wouldn’t hold weight in this specific lawsuit, which deals with damages from the derailment.
“It's not information or evidence that is something we can implement or employ in our case,” he said. “The fact that that came out and that the NTSB reported on it after the settlement was reached is something of a red herring.”
Because residents face another deadline soon — on Aug. 22 — to file claims, Mr. Gomez said he expects the court will issue a ruling on the opt-out issue soon.
“At this point, the schedule remains unchanged, which means that if you have not opted out, you should be getting ready to file your claim by Aug. 22,” Mr. Gomez said. “These deadlines are hard and fast and they're set by the court. I'd say it’s highly unlikely that there are going to be any do-overs or opportunities for folks that miss them.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.