The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation will negotiate with a nine-member group of contractors headed by an Australian firm to replace nine bridges proposed for tolling at an estimated cost of $2.5 billion.
The group — which calls itself Bridging Pennsylvania Partners — lists Macquarie Infrastructure Developments LLC of Sydney as the lead contractor and includes FCC Construccion, S.A., of Spain, as well as six Pennsylvania companies. They include Joseph B. Fay Co. and Shikun & Binui America Inc., of Pittsburgh.
The contract will require that 65% of the work be done by Pennsylvania firms.
State Sen. Wayne Langerholc Jr., R-Johnstown and chairman of the Senate Transportation Committee, blasted the decision to negotiate with a team headed by a non-Pennsylvania firm and the idea of adding tolls during a time of record inflation. He vowed to “do everything I can” to stop the proposal from moving forward.
PennDOT Secretary Yassmin Gramian said in a news release that selecting the team “brings us one step closer” to replacing the bridges, but no work is expected until late 2023 or early 2024. In addition to negotiating details of the deal with BPP, the state also has to complete federally required environmental assessments of the areas around the nine proposed bridges — including the Interstate 79 bridge near Bridgeville — and get approval to charge tolls.
The public comment period for the Bridgeville area isn’t scheduled to begin until May.
Read More
“The environmental work is still happening,” PennDOT spokeswoman Alexis Campbell said. “The bridges are all in different stages of the environmental process. We’re not ready to build anything.”
The proposed project, known as a public-private partnership, will involve using funds from tolls of $1 or $2 per vehicle to pay for the replacement of major bridges that PennDOT says it doesn’t have the funds to replace. The bridges would be turned over to the private team that would construct and maintain them for 30 years.
PennDOT has pledged that any toll revenue not needed to pay for the work and a reserve fund would be used to upgrade roads around the tolled bridges, which could face additional traffic from motorists trying to avoid the tolls.
Critics say the state should use the $4 billion over five years in federal money the state is getting as a result of the Biden administration’s infrastructure bill to replace the bridges. But the department claims that money will help but isn’t nearly enough because the state is only spending about $6.9 billion of the $15 billion it needs annually for roads and bridges.
Mr. Langerholc said PennDOT is “tone deaf” for continuing to pursue the bridge tolling plan and choosing a group headed by a foreign company. He has proposed what he calls the DRIVE SMART plan that would authorize the state to issue up to $2 billion in federal bonds, but PennDOT has rejected that idea because it believes the cost of issuing the bonds would reduce the amount of money available.
“It’s absolutely ridiculous,” the senator said. “This cannot stand. We have plenty of Pennsylvania companies that are more than qualified to do this work. They wrote the specifications so that no state company could be the lead.”
Mr. Langerholc said he has talked with “plenty” to state firms that didn’t want to be part of an international partnership because they believe subcontractors “get nickeled and dimed to death” when they are part of a large group. He also said he doesn’t expect all nine bridges to be part of the final project.
Groups of residents who live around the bridges proposed for tolling have reacted angrily to the project, saying that in addition to putting more traffic on local roads tolling would increase costs for local businesses and amount to an additional tax on local motorists. South Fayette and other communities around the Bridgeville project have filed a lawsuit, claiming the state violated its own procedures in pursuing the project without approval of the Legislature. The Legislature is considering a bill to require its approval before this project could proceed.
Three groups initially expressed interest in the project, but one previously dropped out and the department chose this group because of its experience in similar projects, Ms. Campbell said. The state will negotiate the cost of the contract, the order in which the bridges would be replaced and other details with the chosen team.
“That’s all going to be hammered out in the negotiations,” she said.
Macquarie, based in Sydney, Australia, is a diversified international company that has branches that manage, finance and build infrastructure projects, including roads, bridges, hospitals and other facilities. It formed in 1969 as a spinoff from an English bank and has been operating in the U.S. since 1996 with its financial arm based in Philadelphia.
It has been involved in numerous public-private projects around the world, where they are more popular. In the U.S., the company was the lead contractor for the $1.5 billion project to replace the Goethals Bridge that connects Elizabethtown, N.J., with Staten Island, N.Y., and is part of a public-private partnership to add express lanes to Interstate 270 and the American Legion Memorial Bridge that connects Maryland with Fairfax, Va., as an estimated cost of $4 billion.
In Pennsylvania, Macquarie will head the financing component of the project while FCC Construccion oversees construction.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.