HARRISBURG — The number of speeders nabbed by speed cameras in work zones jumped 53% over 2020’s total in just the first three quarters of the year, PennDOT data shows.
The cameras were approved under Act 86 of 2018.
Motorists will only be ticketed if they exceed the speed limit by 11 miles-per-hour and there are workers present.
Alabama, Arizona, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Iowa, Louisiana, Maryland, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Washington and the District of Columbia currently have speed camera programs in place, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, signed into law by President Joe Biden last week includes language encouraging states to expand automated enforcement programs in work zones and schools.
However, PennDOT can’t expand the pilot program without legislation passed by the General Assembly, said Alexis Campbell, a PennDOT spokeswoman.
The department is still monitoring the rollout of the work zone speed enforcement program and hasn’t made a decision about whether to lobby to get it made permanent, she said.
Critics say the federal legislation doesn’t provide sufficient guidance to be confident that any additional expansions of automated enforcement will treat drivers fairly.
“The infrastructure bill slid in federal money for the promotion of automated traffic enforcement of various types. As usual, there is no provision to require best practice engineering and enforcement. Cameras cannot exist under these conditions, since poor engineering and predatory ticketing are common. Cameras are already a for-profit industry, so expect them to blanket the country,” said James Sikorski, Jr., Pennsylvania advocate for the National Motorists Association. “Why do we not try the carrot approach? Use proper engineering and enforcement, but add a twist. Maybe have a prize drawing for people who obey the law, rather than ticket those who disobey? Reward good driving. Will never happen,” he said.
The automated work zone speed enforcement, a five-year pilot program, launched in the spring of 2020, just as the COVID-19 pandemic began to hit the state. The program began on March 9, 2020, and then was paused a week later, as the Wolf administration began mitigation efforts to try to control the spread of the virus. The speed cameras were placed back into action a month later, but the pandemic continued to depress traffic through much of the year. However, PennDOT reports that during the pandemic shutdown, drivers who found themselves surrounded by little other traffic were more likely to speed.
Because the automated speed enforcement program operated for a little more than eight months in 2020, the data on tickets through the end of September of this year is close to a comparable time period.
Already, by the end of September, the speed cameras in the work zones had flagged 335,647 speeders.
Of those:
— 284,293 were first-time violators, who would not have been fined;
— 35,914 were second-time violators, who would be subject to a $75 fine;
— 15,440 were speeders who’d been caught three or more times and would be subject to a $150 fine.
In 2020, the automated speed enforcement program issued 219,200 violations:
— 191,600 to first-time violators;
— 19,200 to second-time violators;
— 8,400 to drivers caught three or more times.
But only about 70% of drivers who received tickets paid them, according to PennDOT. The only statutory recourse against non-paying violators is to send those violations to a collection agency.
As a result, in its first year of operation, the automated speed enforcement program ended up costing the state $1.4 million more than it brought in through fine revenue.
The costs included $450,000 billed to the program by the state police, along with almost $3 million in costs billed by contractors who operated the automated speed enforcement program.
RedFlex Traffic Systems, an Arizona-based company, was paid $1.47 million as system administrator, and an engineering firm based in Baltimore, RK&K, was paid $1.5 million to serve as program administrator.
The number of total crashes dropped substantially last year with the total number of crashes, number of people injured and number killed all down in 2020 from 2019.
In 2019, there were 1,754 total crashes in work zones on all Pennsylvania roadways. On PennDOT and Turnpike Commission roadways, 44.6% of the crashes included fatalities or injuries. There were 1,074 injured persons resulting from work zone crashes and 16 persons fatally injured, with none of the fatalities being workers within the work zone.
In 2020, there were 1,292 total crashes in work zones, with 45.9% of those crashes involving injuries or deaths. Fifteen people were killed in work zone crashes last year including one construction worker.
Just over 60% of the speeders ticketed in 2020 were Pennsylvania drivers
Last year, 28.36% of drivers passing through work zones when the enforcement equipment was operating were speeding. But just 4.74% were driving 11 mph over the speed limit — the threshold to trigger a violation warning or a ticket.
When the speed cameras were unveiled, proponents touted the technology as a means of prodding drivers to slow down. They pointed to data from Maryland, where 7% of motorists were found to be speeding when that state rolled out speed cameras. But according to the Maryland Department of Transportation’s data, last year, less than 1% of drivers in work zones in that state were driving fast enough to trigger a ticket.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.