The U.S. Supreme Court has been asked to decide whether the Pennsylvania Turnpike is illegally overcharging motorists to collect money for non-turnpike costs such as public transit.

Attorneys for the Owner Operator Independent Drivers Association Inc. filed a petition Thursday asking the court to review its case, which claims the turnpike has collected more than $6 billion in tolls illegally since a 2007 state law required the turnpike to help pay for public transit. The law initially required the turnpike to pass on $900 million a year to the state Department of Transportation but that figure was later cut to $450 million.

U.S. District Court in Harrisburg and the Third Circuit Court of Appeals both have ruled against the truck drivers. But attorneys for the group said in their petition there has been disagreement among the appeals courts on similar issues, so it asked the high court to take the case.

In its petition, the association claims the turnpike collects tolls that provide 250% to 300% of the cost of operating the turnpike. The truckers say this should be illegal under the federal dormant commerce clause, which they say means tolls can only be used for turnpike expenses.

Advertise with us

In addition, the higher-than-necessary tolls violate federal law by restricting travel, they claim.

Rulings in District Court in April and in the Third Circuit in August disagreed, saying Congress didn’t prohibit the use of tolls for other purposes and travel isn’t restricted because motorists could travel other routes without tolls.

“Never in the history of the United States has Congress or a court concluded user fees of this magnitude are constitutionally appropriate,” the request for Supreme Court review said. “The Third Circuit’s decision sanctions these excessive tolls and permits states to charge unlimited tolls on federal-aid highways in violation of the dormant commerce clause and the constitutional right to travel.”

The lawsuit initially prevented the turnpike from borrowing the money it needs to make the annual payments to PennDOT, holding up capital improvement projects at transit agencies such as Port Authority across the state for more than eight months. But after U.S. District Court ruled in its favor, the turnpike was able to borrow money to resume the payments.

The turnpike and PennDOT have been lobbying the Legislature to change the laws for financing public transit for several years and lawmakers are expected to address the issue next year. The annual payments are scheduled to be reduced to $50 million a year in 2023, but the House and Senate are considering legislation to make that change sooner by identifying other funding for public transit.

The turnpike declined to comment.