A mediator will help settle the concerns of neighborhood groups on Pittsburgh’s North Side about Norfolk Southern’s plans to run double-stacked freight cars and double the amount of trains there.

Attorney David Wolf, representing the Northside Leadership Conference, said last week that he and the railroad are in the process of choosing a mediator to help work out the issues between the railroad and the neighborhood, which include making neighborhood bridges higher, noise, pollution and the cargo the trains will carry.

The railroad wants to use a $20 million grant from the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation to raise the height of two North Side bridges, lower the railroad bed at another and replace a fourth bridge at the same level to allow the trains. The railroad says it would contribute $8.2 million to improve the route, which also passes through the city’s East End and eastern suburbs and would provide a shorter, second path along with the one that already carries double-stacked cars along Carson Street on the city’s South Side.

On a parallel track, PennDOT has released a consultant’s report that the agency says is “not very conclusive” about the best way to accommodate double-stacked cars. Cheryl Moon-Sirianni, district executive for PennDOT’s District 11, said the agency has begun public engagement about the work and will hold a series of public meetings early next year for residents to present their concerns about the project.

Advertise with us

The agency will use that input to work with the railroad on its plans.

Although the railroad already has done some work in suburban areas as part of the project, major changes on the North Side have been on hold since the grant was announced in April 2017. The railroad wants to raise bridges at Pennsylvania and West North avenues to create more clearance under them, lower the tracks under the Columbus Avenue Bridge and replace the Merchant Street Bridge that carries the railroad above the street near the D.L. Clark Building.

The parties reached the point of trying mediation after the neighborhood groups tried to intervene in the Public Utility Commission’s consideration of the proposed changes to the bridges. The PUC ruled against the groups, but Commonwealth Court said after an appeal that it wants to hear arguments about the issue.

The arguments have been delayed at least 90 days to allow mediation.

Mr. Wolf said he’s committed to working with the railroad to find the best method of allowing double-stacked freight cars to pass through the North Side and thought it would be reasonable to reach an agreement sometime next year. In most areas, the tracks already are sunken below street level but the railroad has said it’s too expensive and there are concerns about sewer lines and other utilities below them to sink them even lower.

Advertise with us

“We’re here to come to a resolution,” Mr. Wolf said. “We’re not trying to be obstructionists. There may be some way to solve this in between what the railroad wants and what the neighborhood wants.

“One thing I always say about mediation is nobody’s going to hit a home run and be completely happy with everything.”

Rudy Husband, the railroad’s vice president for government relations in Pennsylvania, declined to comment on whether the railroad has agreed to mediation. He said the railroad is “just continuing to work through the approval process” and is “having conversations” with neighborhood groups.

Neighborhood groups don’t seem as flexible as Mr. Wolf suggested.

Mark Fatla, executive director of the Leadership Conference, said he is “open to mediation” but he said the railroad has to do its part. The railroad hasn’t provided any information comparing the costs and environmental impact of raising the bridges or lowering the tracks, as the neighborhood would prefer.

Advertise with us

“It would have to be real and we’d have to have information so we can have substantive conversations,” Mr. Fatla said. “Sadly, the railroad hasn’t been forthcoming about engaging with the community so far.”

Plans call for increasing the number of trains traveling through the North Side from 20 to 25 a day to 40 to 50. That’s also a concern for residents.

“The volume means increased noise, increased pollution and increased risk,” Mr. Fatla said. “The chance for a catastrophe goes up.”

The noise concern was highlighted last month when officials from PennDOT, the railroad and the neighborhood had an outdoor meeting interrupted by a freight train passing through the area.

John DeSantis, immediate past president of the Allegheny West Civic Association, said the parties need to start “from a clean sheet” and review all aspects of the project. The refusal to discuss the cargo that the cars would carry needs to change, especially with the trains passing through the city’s most densely populated neighborhoods, he said.

Advertise with us

“I’m hopeful the railroad will get realistic,” Mr. DeSantis said. “They can’t come into mediation and not be wiling to make significant changes.”

From PennDOT’s standpoint, Ms. Moon-Sirianni said the study by Johnson, Mirmiran & Thompson Inc. took a “high-level view” of the project and determined that the two bridges could be raised without causing sight problems for motorists. One concern the consultant mentioned is that if the railroad can’t use the grant to improve the bridges, that responsibility would fall to the city.

Now, the agency wants to hear from the neighborhood, where plans to raise the bridges come with serious changes that include raising streets higher than the sidewalk level.

“I don’t think anybody was super comfortable with the sidewalks,” Ms. Moon-Sirianni said. “There’s a lot of things that can be done to make the raising of the bridges more palatable.”

Mr. Wolf said he doesn’t understand why PennDOT should gather its own information rather than participate in the mediation process.

“Why do the parallel effort?” he asked. “Don’t they think the neighborhood groups adequately represent the North Side?”