A broken rail that caused a Norfolk Southern Railway train to derail last year at Pittsburgh’s Station Square was identified weeks before seven cars jumped the tracks, a Federal Railroad Administration report released Thursday concluded.
The 11-page report said Sperry Rail Service committed “serious oversights” when it failed to follow up on an ultrasound inspection July 16, 2018, that indicated a defect in the track above Station Square. A visual inspection by the railroad Aug. 3 found no defects, but part of the train derailed two days later, splitting open cars and dumping freight onto the Port Authority’s light-rail tracks below.
The derailment closed the railroad tracks for four days, causing $80,000 in damage to Norfolk Southern track and $773,275 in equipment damage. The Port Authority’s light rail system was unable to use the Station Square area for three weeks, and the agency is seeking more than $3 million in track and equipment damages and costs for rerouting service.
The federal report reached the same conclusion as a railroad report in November concerning what caused the derailment: a detail fracture, which is described as a progressive break beginning at or near the rail surface. But the railroad didn’t mention the problem had been identified by an outside contractor and could have been corrected three weeks earlier.
The railroad, in a statement Friday, said, “The FRA report is factually accurate. Norfolk Southern has been working with Sperry on improved human procedures and oversight to ensure that this type of error does not happen again.”
Sperry, whose website says it is the largest train inspection contractor in the world and whose founder invented the non-destructive testing method still in use, said it does not take calls from reporters.
Read More
The company was involved in a similar incident in 2015, when 27 of 109 CSX train cars derailed in Mount Carbon, W. Va, spilling 362,300 gallons of crude oil and requiring more than 1,000 residents to evacuate.
A Sperry operator had inspected the flawed portion of the track twice in the months leading up to the failure. Both times, the images indicated a flaw, the second time bigger than the first. But the operator did not get out of the car to inspect the area closer because, he told the FRA, he assumed the test image was a result of the rough track rather than a defect. Both CSX and Sperry were fined $25,000 for the event.
According to Nortfolk Southern’s corporate responsibility report, the company had an average of 217 accidents between 2015 and 2017, the latest dates available.
The federal report said Sperry inspects Norfolk Southern track twice a year and, during the July 16 inspection, two ultrasound images showed the broken rail.
“The operator’s decision to disregard induction channel responses from the initial test and not utilize camera images were serious oversights,” the report said. “It was evident that the Sperry chief operator had multiple opportunities to recognize a potential defect at the [point of derailment] and follow up with a ground inspection.”
The report said rail testing experts agreed that the operator should have performed other tests, based on “multiple sources of rail inspection information available to the operator during the Sperry car test.”
The report said it was “unusual” for trains to run on broken track for three weeks without a derailment. It speculated that a rail anchor may have reduced the movement of the broken rail and allowed trains to pass over it until the day of the derailment, when a 16-inch piece broke.
“It appears the anchor may have spanned the break from the time of the Sperry test to the derailment, serving as a clamp to minimize relative rail-end movement and, more importantly, as an electrical connection between the rail ends,” the report said. “The anchor provided continuity for the track circuit and allowed trains to run on signal indication.”
According to railsystem.net, track circuits work by running an electrical circuit using the rails to connect a power source at one end of a block of track with a relay at the far end. If the circuit is broken, the system fails, notifying the railroad that the tracks are not safe.
The Port Authority expressed “significant concerns” about the safety of Norfolk Southern operating trains with double-stacked cars when it filed its reimbursement claim with the railroad in January. The agency called for more frequent track inspections and other safety assurances from the railroad.
Spokesman Adam Brandolph said the new accident report reinforced the authority’s concerns.
“I would think those concerns are only more founded today than they were,” he said, “and we continue to have significant reservations about the operation of double-stacked cars.”
Mr. Brandolph said the agency and railroad had “agreed in principle” about the cost of damages from the derailment but were still working out details.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.