After more than 10 years of discussing, studying and lobbying about more passenger rail service from Pittsburgh to the east, only one thing is settled: If there is more service, it will be costly.

The push for more passenger rail service began almost immediately after Amtrak cut the Pennsylvanian from twice daily trips from Pittsburgh to New York City to once a day in 2005. Service between Harrisburg and Philadelphia has steadily increased since then, but there remains only one daily trip between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg.

Over the years, efforts to increase service from Pittsburgh have ebbed and flowed with studies from the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and other groups periodically estimating the cost of more train service. But little has actually happened.

Those efforts are swinging upward again with PennDOT recently completing one study of more service from Pittsburgh to Altoona and negotiating the cost of another study by Norfolk Southern, which owns the tracks throughout the corridor. The Norfolk Southern study would project the cost of track changes the railroad might need to accommodate more passenger trains on tracks it uses mainly to move million of tons of freight.

Advertise with us

In addition, state Rep. Lou Schmitt, R-Altoona, will hold a hearing at 3 p.m. Wednesday at the Altoona Railroaders Memorial Museum for an update on expansion efforts. Mr. Schmitt, chair of the House Transportation Committee’s subcommittee on railroads, expects to hear from PennDOT, Norfolk Southern, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership and Western Pennsylvanians for Passenger Rail, among others.

“I want to hear where things stand,” Mr. Schmitt said. “There has been a lot of talk but not a lot of action.”

Mr. Schmitt said it is important for leaders to consider expanding group transportation services such as passenger rail.

“As we move forward, we have to focus on moving a lot of people at once, not single-person vehicles with internal combustion engines,” he said.

Norfolk Southern’s review would be a follow-up to PennDOT’s 2015 Keystone West High Speed Rail study, which projected it would cost $1.5 billion to $10 billion to increase service between Harrisburg and Pittsburgh, depending on the amount of track improvements to cut travel time. That estimate didn’t include the changes Norfolk Southern might need, such as creating side tracks where freight trains could pull over to allow faster passenger trains to pass.

Advertise with us

Norfolk Southern couldn’t be reached for comment on how long the study might take.

In the Pittsburgh-to-Altoona study, completed in June and obtained by the Post-Gazette, PennDOT projected the minimum cost of providing three daily round trips at $1.2 billion for track and station improvements. Gov. Tom Wolf requested that study in September.

If the project included adding a third track, the cost would increase to $3.7 billion. Again, those estimates don’t include any changes Norfolk Southern might need.

The study concluded that adding two more trips between Altoona and Pittsburgh would increase daily ridership by about 130 to about 250 passengers by 2040, raising ridership to about 1,100 a day. A key finding is that about 60 percent of those passengers would be traveling from Greensburg to Pittsburgh, the shortest leg of the route at 31 miles or about 40 minutes.

“That’s a lot of money,” Mr. Schmitt said. “My guess is that’s so high PennDOT won’t go ahead with it. The cost of transportation and mobility upgrades is mind-boggling.”

Advertise with us

Lucinda Beattie, a longtime rail advocate at the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership who will testify at Wednesday’s hearing, said Pittsburgh to Altoona isn’t a good route for judging ridership interest.

“”[Pittsburgh] needs to be part of a larger route. Altoona isn’t far enough,” she said. “From a business standpoint, Philadelphia is the largest job center followed by Downtown Pittsburgh and Oakland. Why aren’t there better connections between the largest job centers?”

Ms. Beattie questioned the $1.2 billion cost for service to Altoona, noting that a 2013 study by her organization showed costs of $10 million to $13 million for an additional train from Pittsburgh to Harrisburg. But even that higher cost shouldn’t be prohibitive, she said.

“It’s not something where you have to come up with $1.2 billion in one chunk,” she said. “It’s been done [between Harrisburg and Philadelphia] a little bit at a time.”

Ms. Beattie described adding passenger rail service as “a complex issue” and said she isn’t frustrated by the lack of action.

Advertise with us

“Are we closer? This is a long process,” she said. “It’s not something that’s done in a year or even 10 years.

“This is better than we’ve been before. It’s really a question of slow and steady progress.”

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.