To Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale, the state Turnpike Commission’s decision Tuesday to raise tolls for the 11th year in a row highlights a fundamental mistake the state made more than 10 years ago.
Beginning Jan. 6, the most common toll for a passenger vehicle will increase from $1.30 to $1.38 for E-ZPass customers; from $2.10 to $2.25 for cash customers; and from $6.75 to $7.20 for Toll By Plate. For Class-5 tractor-trailer trucks, the fee for the most common tolls will increase from $3.45 to $3.66 for E-ZPass and from $15.35 to $16.30 for cash.
For passenger vehicles that travel the length of the turnpike, the toll will increase from $55 to $58.30 and for E-ZPass users from $39.25 to $41.60.
Mr. DePasquale said the annual spikes -- born out of a decision a decade ago -- could lead to problems down the road.
When the federal government turned down then-Gov. Ed Rendell’s effort to charge tolls on Interstate 80 to increase transportation funding, Mr. DePasquale said, the state should have eliminated the turnpike’s obligation to help pay for public transit. In anticipation of the turnpike receiving I-80 tolls, the Legislature required the agency to help pay for public transit, originally $900 million a year but later reduced to $450 million, and didn’t eliminate the payment when the toll plan was rejected.
Now, the turnpike is saddled with the annual payment through 2022, after which it will be cut to $50 million.
To make that annual payment and upgrade the highway — parts of which are still original construction from the 1940s — the turnpike has been raising tolls annually and borrowing money. About two-thirds of its $900 million annual budget is for debt service.
“I get why they have to raise tolls,” said Mr. DePasquale. “I have more of a general concern that this pattern of raising tolls and increasing ridership isn’t sustainable.
“There’s going to have to be a fundamental change in the structure so it doesn’t become a financial disaster.”
His fear is that motorists will find alternate routes to avoid turnpike tolls. In January, he announced the agency would begin its third audit of the agency since 2010 after traffic figures fell short of projections in October and November.
Traffic has leveled off since then, the agency said, though exact figures were unavailable Tuesday. The audit is expected to be done by the end of the year.
The commission’s decision will increase rates for cash customers; motorists who use the E-ZPass system, where an in-vehicle transponder is linked to a credit card; and those who use Toll By Plate, where vehicles pass through cashless toll sites without E-ZPass and drivers are mailed a bill as a result of a camera taking a photo of their license plate.
Several times, the commission has issued a lower increase for E-ZPass users to convert more drivers to the system, but this year’s increase applies to all motorists.
The commission said the money is needed for infrastructure.
“Parts of our tollway will soon turn 78 years old, and we owe it to toll-paying customers to continue to invest in our road to make it safer, smoother and wider,” turnpike CEO Mark Compton said in a news release. “This year, about 84 percent of our $552 million capital budget is focused on renewing, rebuilding and widening our highway system, which last year carried more than 200 million vehicles.”
So far, the agency has rebuilt more than 132 miles of its system. Another 19 miles are being rebuilt and widened now and more than 82 miles are currently in planning and design phases.
Last year, amid indications that the Legislature wasn’t interested in changing the turnpike’s transit obligations due to the state’s own financial difficulties, the agency decided to follow a four-year budget plan to get by until that payment is cut to $50 million. Mr. DePasquale said the state has to pay attention to the turnpike’s financial situation.
“Can they make it [four more years]? Yes,” Mr. DePasquale said. “But they’re going to continue to bleed money until then.”
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.