Michael Fabacher of Honey Brook, Pa., Chester County, is finding out the hard way what can happen when motorists don’t pay tolls on the Pennsylvania Turnpike: He’s facing third-degree felony charges that carry a potential of seven years in jail and a fine of $15,000.
Mr. Fabacher is among about 20 motorists across the state to face the first-ever round of criminal charges for unpaid turnpike tolls. As part of a stepped-up enforcement program, the turnpike — which has more than $17 million in unpaid tolls — also has had the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation for the first time suspend the vehicle registrations of 83 motorists with unpaid tolls of more than $500 who commit new violations.
“If you believed you could do this over and over and nobody would pay any attention … that has changed,” said Craig Shuey, the turnpike’s chief operating officer.
Mr. Fabacher runs East Wind Transport, a trucking company with one driver other than himself. He claims he didn’t know his other driver was not paying turnpike tolls that reached $29,162 because the driver’s girlfriend kept the books for the company and never told him about repeated notices from the turnpike about unpaid tolls.
Once he found out, Mr. Fabacher said, he fired the driver and bookkeeper and made arrangements for monthly payments.
In February, he was a little short on cash and said he was unsuccessful in finding the right person at the turnpike to ask for a delay. Then a constable called to tell him a warrant had been issued and he was required to be at the district judge’s office the next morning to answer criminal charges.
Read More
“I am guilty as charged,” Mr. Fabacher said in an interview Friday. “But the biggest thing was never being able to find the right person at the turnpike to talk to about coming up a little short that month. It was a communication problem and now I’m dealing with it.”
Mr. Shuey and Ray Morrow, the turnpike’s chief compliance officer, said the agency is going after the worst offenders first — those with more than $2,000 in unpaid tolls and fees — but is working its way down the list to those with smaller amounts. They urged motorists who have received numerous notices about unpaid tolls to respond before their name is next on the enforcement list.
When drivers go through the E-ZPass lane on the turnpike, they are supposed to have a transponder linked to a credit card for payment. But some drivers blow through the E-ZPass lane without a transponder, either by mistake or figuring they can avoid paying the toll.
But each E-ZPass lane also has a camera that takes a photo of the vehicle’s license plate and the agency sends bills to those who haven’t paid.
Enforcement is a complicated process that involves numerous notices before the turnpike can take action. For example, those motorists who have had their vehicle registrations revoked had received 23,967 notices that they owed unpaid tolls worth $528,327 and another $958,674 in administrative fees.
Revoking vehicle registrations is a new tool that became available in August of last year. Once a motorist has six or more unpaid tolls or owes more than $500 in unpaid tolls, the turnpike sends a notice to pay within 30 days. If the tolls aren’t paid, then a final notice is sent with another 30-day deadline to pay the tolls or request an administrative hearing.
If the tolls still aren’t paid, the agency turns over scofflaws to PennDOT. PennDOT then sends the motorist a Notice of Suspension that takes effect 42 days from the date of the letter.
When the turnpike sends out a suspension warning or makes contact with a motorist about possible criminal charges, Mr.Morrow said, it is wiling to accept payment of overdue tolls either immediately or by payment plan and waive administrative fees. If the motorist misses a payment, they move directly to suspension or criminal charges.
Once criminal charges are filed, Mr. Morrow said, arrangements are subject to a court order and a judge could refuse to allow fees to be waived.
Mr. Morrow said he is working with district attorneys in 13 of the 15 counties the turnpike passes through. After the agency initially filed private complaints, Dauphin County prosecutors have agreed to file charges and others are expected to follow. Several criminal cases have been through preliminary hearings, which the defendants often have waived, and are awaiting action in Common Pleas Court.
Michael Sprow, first assistant district attorney who is prosecuting several of the cases in Dauphin County, said the cases aren’t difficult. The turnpike has photos of the vehicles and copies of the notices that have been sent to the offending motorists.
“It’s pretty straight forward,” Mr. Sprow said. “For people who go to court, there’s not much to argue because we have the photos.
“Rightfully so, they get multiple chances to take care of this before it gets to court. Either they make an honest mistake or they just don’t pay, [but] they have had a chance to take care of it.”
Mr. Fabacher said he has a court appearance in early June where he will find out whether he can avoid a criminal conviction in the case. He willingly pays about $3,500 a month in tolls from Ohio, Indiana, Illinois and Massachusetts, as well as Pennsylvania, he said, even if he sometimes questions whether weigh stations accurately record how much his trucks are carrying to set the toll.
“I was wrong doing it and we’re trying to get it right,” he said. “This was out of my control at one point. I’m a pretty good guy, and I don’t want to end up with a criminal record over this.”
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.