New CEO Katharine Eagan Kelleman is beginning to make her mark at the Port Authority.
For the second time this month, Ms. Kelleman announced Friday the agency would make major revisions in policy proposals that had been under development for several years. This time, Ms. Kelleman said the agency is dropping two-year-old plans to shift to cashless fares on the light-rail system and therefore won’t follow through on a controversial proposal to use armed police officers to enforcement fare payment.
Two weeks ago, the authority announced that bus riders from the Monongahela Valley and some eastern neighborhoods won’t have to transfer to the Bus Rapid Transit system in Oakland when it opens in a few years if they want to travel Downtown and their neighborhood service won’t be sharply reduced. That had been a key part of saving money with the new system but when riders complained that cuts would hurt some of the poorest communities in the county, Ms. Kelleman had staff review plans and decided neighborhood buses could use the dedicated BRT lanes without cutting service.
Ms. Kelleman, who took office in January, told the authority’s board Friday that her review of the fare policy concluded it didn’t make financial sense to go to cashless light-rail fares because not all of its stations have vending machines for riders to put more money on prepaid ConnectCards or buy daily ride tickets. Installing the equipment in those stations would cost at least $60,000 each, she said.
“The possibility a person could have $2.75 in their hand and can’t ride because they couldn’t buy a ticket doesn’t make sense,” she said. “Our goal should always be, ‘How do we make it easy.’”
In addition, a review of fare evasion on the light-rail system showed that about 2 percent of riders don’t tap their fare card or pay cash, a fare evasion rate among the best in the country, Ms. Kelleman said. That — and eliminating the honor system element involved in the cashless system — mean’s there’s no reason to use armed officers for fare enforcement, she said.
Read More
“We will not be using our police officers for primary fare enforcement,” she said. “It creates barriers where we don’t need them.”
As a result, the agency will continue to use 18 fare-checkers to check whether riders are paying. The authority’s 47-member police force — including 10 officers hired over the past two years in anticipation of handling fare enforcement — have plenty of police work to do, Ms. Kelleman said.
Although fare enforcement is an administrative issue, Ms. Kelleman said board members had made their feelings known about the issue. Chairman Jeffrey Letwin called the decisions “the right step.”
In addition, a coalition of community groups has been lobbying against using armed officers for fare enforcement for more than a year and favored civil enforcement of fare evasion, similar to a parking ticket. They were concerned that students, riders who don't speak English and those with mental health issues could have deadly confrontations with armed officers if they don't understand the system.
Laura Wiens of Pittsburghers for Public Transit said she was “glad” the Port Authority listened to the coalition’s concerns that using armed officers could result in dangerous consequences “to address a problem that doesn’t exist.”
“We believe our toll booth collectors and drivers do a great job collecting fares and police should be there to handle legitimate safety issues that arise,” she said.
Cashless fares were scheduled to begin last summer, but the company that provides equipment to read prepaid ConnectCards had trouble updating existing equipment and was late providing 10 additional machines because of software problems. Those machines still haven’t been delivered because the company is upgrading it’s entire software system, authority spokesman Adam Brandolph said, but the authority still wants them when they are ready next year.
Even though the light-rail fare system isn’t changing, the authority will follow through with an education campaign to make sure irregular riders know how to pay when they get on, Mr. Brandolph said. That is expected to begin in June and last several months.
“It’s going to be a campaign on how to ride the light-rail system and pay your fair share,” Mr. Brandolph said. “People who don’t ride regularly don’t know whether to pay when they get on or where they pay, whatever. We want to eliminate those barriers.”
The recent issues all deal with Ms. Kelleman’s core philosophy of trying to provide an effective, efficient transit system for the public.
“In all of these situations, I ask, ‘What problem are we solving,’” Ms. Kelleman said. “None of these things would make it easier for our customers.”
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.