Bar and restaurant owners are concerned that a recommendation to reduce the blood-alcohol level for drunken driving from 0.08 to 0.05 percent could have “a chilling effect” and cause patrons to stay home.
The recommendation was part of a nearly 500-page study released Wednesday by a panel of the National Academies of Sciences, Medicine and Engineering. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration commissioned the study in 2016 after alcohol-related traffic deaths climbed for two years in a row after plateauing at just over 10,000 for several years.
The report makes a series of recommendations such as increased alcohol taxes, limited hours for alcohol sales, stronger controls on the contents of alcohol advertising and marketing, and wider use of ignition locks and sobriety checkpoints.
But the most significant recommendation is reducing the blood-alcohol level for drunken driving from 0.08 to 0.05 percent.
“Our apathy toward 29 alcohol-related deaths per day is unacceptable, particularly because these tragic events can be prevented,” committee chairman Steve Teutsch, a senior fellow for health policy and economics at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles, wrote in the study’s introduction.
The panel said drunken driving has been “virtually eliminated” in some of the 35 countries that are part of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development that have adopted similar restrictions and programs. The countries are all democracies that use a market economy.
The panel said research shows that drivers start to become impaired when their blood-alcohol level reaches 0.05 percent, and that should be enough to prohibit them from driving.
“Every time I hear something like this, it scares me,” said Kevin Joyce, owner of the Carlton House restaurant Downtown and past head of the state restaurant association. “I don’t know the science, but I think 0.05 is aggressive … especially for a small person.
“My fear is the people who feel they can’t have a glass of wine with dinner may just stay at home.”
John Longstreet, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Restaurant & Lodging Association, agreed.
“Our fear would be the fear of patrons not understanding how much alcohol they can consume,” he said. “It could have such a chilling effect that they don’t go out.”
If the lower blood-alcohol rate were approved, Mr. Longstreet said, his organization likely would have to launch a marketing campaign to assure the customers they could have a drink or two without breaking the law.
“It’s frankly in nobody’s interest to send somebody out driving who’s had too much to drink and that’s the last thing we want to do,” he said. “But we’d have to tell them it’s OK if they want to have a glass of wine with dinner.”
Mr. Joyce said he’s concerned that reducing the legal limit for driving would be “basically scaring everybody” and wouldn’t reach problem drinkers who he believes are involved in the vast majority of serious crashes. Better policing would catch those drivers, he said.
“The real problem is those folks who are seriously impaired,” he said. “I sell a lot of wine, but people aren’t walking out of my restaurant falling down.”
Attorney Patrick Thomassey, who defends drivers facing charges of driving under the influence, questioned whether the punishment of taking away someone’s license for drunken driving causes more serious problems for society. He’s had clients who can’t get to work to support their families as a result of a drunken driving conviction.
“The fallout [from losing a driver’s license] is what people don’t appreciate unless it directly effects them,” he said. “The true drinkers, no matter what you make [the blood alcohol level] are still going to drive.”
The highway association, which commissioned the study, said in a statement the study “provides a thorough update on scientific literature” and a review of programs to address drunken driving. It has no plans to recommend a change in the blood-alcohol level for drunken driving at this time.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.