Port Authority isn’t sure why, but it’s happy with the trend: The agency is losing less money than it expected since it changed its fare policy at the beginning of 2017.

In January, the transit agency changed from a two-tiered fare system that charged $2.50 for shorter rides and $3.75 for longer rides to a flat $2.50 fare for riders who use the prepaid ConnectCard and $2.75 for cash. It anticipated the change would reduce fare receipts in the short term — about 26 percent of riders had their fares reduced — but expected a long-term payoff through increased ridership and a reduction in staff needed to count cash receipts.

Through the first 11 months of the year, fare receipts are down compared to two years earlier, but not as much as anticipated. The agency expected the loss to be about $6.2 million, but it is only about $4.2 million, said spokesman Adam Brandolph.

“We think it shows a trend. It’s a welcome difference,” Mr. Brandolph said. “It’s a change we had not been anticipating. It’s a significant number.”

Advertise with us

As a result, Mr. Brandolph said, the agency’s finance staff is revising its fare box projections with lower losses as it begins developing a budget for the 2018-19 fiscal year. That budget likely will be presented in May.

What isn’t clear is why the trend has occurred.

Mr. Brandolph said there is no indication that ridership has increased. In fact, January through September ridership numbers for the last three years show the Port Authority had 5,207,243 riders in 2015; 5,197,513 in 2016; and 5,125,510 in 2017.

Among the possibilities, Mr. Brandolph said, are less fare evasion; more customers than expected paying the higher cash rate; and an increase in riders buying weekly or monthly passes and then not using all of the rides.

One reason fare evasion could be down is that when the agency switched to a flat fare it also forced all passengers to enter the front of the bus and pay when entering. Previously, it used a confusing system that allowed passengers to enter any door and pay entering or leaving depending on the time of day, so some passengers may have entered and exited rear doors without paying.

Advertise with us

“Paying on enter and entering in front will have a huge effect on [fare evasion],” he said.

The agency expects to go to cashless fares on the light-rail system to the South Hills after the first quarter next year, requiring riders either to use a ConnectCard or buy a day pass to ride. That also could cause a change in fare receipts.

Although it is adjusting future budget numbers, it is too soon for the agency to reach a conclusion on why it hasn’t lost as much fare box revenue as it expected.

“We want to know why,” Mr. Brandolph said. “That’s important for us to know. But it takes time. We want to see two or three years before we reach any conclusions.”

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.