For years, politicians and lobbying groups on both sides of the aisle have claimed U.S. transportation and water systems are crumbling and the country’s infrastructure is falling behind the rest of the world because of a lack of government spending.

But a study released Tuesday by the Rand Corp. disagrees with that assessment and encourages the Trump administration to target federal spending spending on infrastructure projects that benefit regions or multiple states. Rand is an international research organization that studies public policy challenges.

The 130-page study, “Not Everything Is Broken,” concentrated on transportation and water system projects because those mostly are funded by government at the federal, state and local levels. Other infrastructure, such as utilities and railroads, are mostly funded by private companies.

The study concluded that the “widely held perception” that underspending has resulted in widespread poor conditions for transportation and water systems is wrong on two parts: Spending adjusted for inflation has been mostly stable since the 1950s and, with exceptions in communities with funding problems, conditions generally are not that bad.

Advertise with us

“There are serious infrastructure needs in some places and I don’t want to minimize those,” said Debra Knopman, the Rand researcher who headed the study.

“But to paint the problem with such a broad brush is a misconception. It’s a more nuanced picture than that.”

During last year’s presidential campaign, Donald Trump called for spending $1 trillion to upgrade infrastructure across the country and, after taking office in January, suggested an $800 billion program of tax credits. So far, that hasn’t been a top priority and the administration hasn’t yet released its infrastructure program.

Rand researchers said the 2009 stimulus program under President Barack Obama cast a wide net and included almost any project that was shovel-ready. With the national economy not facing that kind of economic crisis now, any new spending should be vetted for need, benefit and how long it will last, the study said.

“The extent of underinvestment differs markedly by type of infrastructure, its ownership and maintenance arrangements, and the economic fortunes of the region,” the study concluded. “ For this reason, a rapid and substantial ramp-up of federal spending — whether through direct funding, tax credits to private developers, or a combination — will not solve the real infrastructure problems that need fixing unless accompanied by thoughtful consideration of priorities, policy constraints and regional variations.

Advertise with us

“Further, a one-off spike in federal spending could divert local and state governments’ attention away from their longer-term imperative to adopt new technologies and secure sustainable financing.”

The study recommends 10 steps that federal officials should take to deal with infrastructure concerns, including preserving federal tax-exempt bonds and reinstating Build America Bonds (used to fund projects in 2009) for 10 years; considering raising money for transportation projects through fees paid for miles driven rather than a gasoline tax that is producing diminishing returns as vehicles become more energy-efficient; concentrating on federal facilities such as parks, dams and military bases; and making design improvements to reduce damage in areas prone to natural disasters.

It also recommends combining the Army Corps of Engineers and the Bureau of Reclamation into a national water resource agency.

“What we hope the report does is highlight the need for a central vision and priority,” Ms. Knopman said. “There should a a debate about what that vision is.”

The full study is available at www.rand.org.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.