The massive backup that left hundreds stranded on the Pennsylvania Turnpike over the weekend started when two tractor-trailers collided Friday night while traveling side by side in a snowy construction zone as they climbed a hill in Somerset County, the chief executive of the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission said.

“Two tractor-trailers were driving side by side through a cattle chute,” said Mark P. Compton, referring to narrow travel lanes that accommodate construction projects, “and they collided.”

The truck in the right lane shouldn’t have been in that lane, he said, because the construction section restricts trucks to the left lane.

The accident happened at around 8:30 p.m. Friday in the westbound lanes about three miles before the entrance to the Allegheny Mountain Tunnel, on a notoriously steep, winding section of the turnpike.

Advertise with us

Mr. Compton said a police report had not yet been written but that emerging facts point to a trucker’s error at the foundation of a situation that left some 500 vehicles snowbound and forced a shutdown of much of the turnpike until Sunday afternoon.

There is no shoulder on the steep section where the backup occurred.

“On a clear day, it’s very tough,” Mr. Compton noted in an interview Sunday.

At the time of the incident, it was dark and snow was falling, heavy and fast, part of a wide-reaching storm that buffeted the Eastern Seaboard.

While blame for what started the incident may be nailed down soon, it’s expected to take weeks to determine what went wrong in resolving it. Many motorists spent 24 hours stuck on the road, and vehicles weren’t completely cleared until Sunday afternoon.

Advertise with us

Turnpike commission chairman Sean Logan of Monroeville issued a formal apology and promised a thorough review: “I can promise you all that there will be a thorough analysis of the events that led up to this incident as well as a review of what occurred over the course of the last two and a half days. I want to be certain that we do a better job the next time something like this occurs, and that we can learn from this tragedy.”

Mr. Compton conceded “there are a lot of things I can own” in terms of the strategy that was employed to clear and reopen the highway. He said an “after-action review” will start this week, and estimated it would take at least a few weeks, given the scope of the event — which he described as “historic in nature” — though he was quick to emphasize that no one was injured or killed.

“There’s no question there are improvements we can make,” Mr. Compton said, praising as perfect, however, the 300 or so turnpike workers responding to the crisis.

Mr. Compton said efforts to remove the two tractor-trailers that stretched across the snowy, uphill stretch of highway were complicated by several factors:

• A higher volume of westbound traffic (much of it motorists fleeing west and north from blizzard-stricken areas) that quickly became a lengthy stack behind the disabled tractor-trailers.

Advertise with us

• Heavy snowfall that began piling up, reaching a couple of feet before the storm was spent, making it more difficult for vehicles to move up the hill and for crews to clear the roadway.

• The lack of a berm in the highway’s construction zone from which heavy-duty tow-trucks could operate.

Despite the difficult conditions, questions remain on whether the road was adequately treated before the tractor-trailers jackknifed, whether officials should have shut down the roadway sooner and how responders could have cleared the roadway sooner, and whether enough groundwork had been laid for “Plan X,” a strategy to turn motorists around and get them off the road in the opposite-direction lanes.

State Transportation Secretary Leslie S. Richards, who oversaw the efforts of scores of state employees in dealing with roadway messes on the eastern side of the state during the weekend, was hesitant to make a judgment about how the turnpike commission might have cleared the traffic and reopened the highway sooner. She will participate in the after-action review.

“These are good questions,” she said. “I know that we will go over this whole situation minute by minute to see what could have been done differently.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Compton said there was no indication that the road hadn’t been properly treated at the time the incident began.

“Our crews were in plow trains, working in tandem, cycling through their sections of the roadway. … I know our crews do an outstanding job. They fight that mountain. They know that mountain,’’ he said.

At a news conference Sunday, Gov. Tom Wolf said the storm started earlier and reached farther west than had been expected. Still, he apologized to the people “trapped” on the turnpike and conceded “we have to figure out how to do a better job there.”

Richard D. Flinn Jr., director of the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency, called the turnpike crisis “our primary focus; the center of gravity” Friday and Saturday.

As the state’s chief emergency responder who has been involved in drafting protocols about whether and when to shut down limited access highways, he said he believes the turnpike made a correct call in not opting to shut down the highway before the storm started, or even after it began laying down snow.

Advertise with us

“You have to think of the second, third and fourth effects of shutting a road down,’’ he said, noting that municipal road crews often aren’t capable of keeping pace with a big storm and that shutting down a highway can mean sending motorists into an unsafe local road system.

“I don’t believe there’s any indication they needed to close the road” at the start of the storm, he said, noting that at 8:30 p.m. the commission implemented restrictions that lowered the highway speed to 45 mph, restricted empty, double and oversized commercial trailers, and forbade motorists from pulling trailers. Those restrictions had been planned for midnight but were moved up after a westbound tractor-trailer slid off the road around 6:30 p.m. and weather conditions worsened, according to Carl DeFebo, a spokesman for the turnpike.

The turnpike’s westbound lanes initially were closed from the Bedford to Somerset interchanges between about midnight and 1 a.m. Saturday. At 11 a.m. on Saturday, the turnpike was closed in both directions between the New Stanton and Bedford interchanges.

In the end, officials worked together to implement “Plan X,” which involved turning vehicles around so they could exit the turnpike in the opposite direction. But, for that to happen, crew members had to shovel vehicles out or use small snow-clearing equipment.

Local firefighters, state troopers, road crew employees and the National Guard worked to refuel vehicles, conduct safety checks, shovel snow, hand out food and water and give vehicles a push. A news release from the governor’s office put the number at 135 initial responders — a figure that grew to 250. That was in addition to 300 or so turnpike employees who were on the job throughout the weekend.

Advertise with us

Heavy equipment had to be brought in to pull out concrete barriers to allow motorists to cross to the eastbound lanes once they were able to move.

Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or 724-772-9180.