It's a question that has vexed even the most seasoned Pittsburgh motorists.
If PennDOT sets up a construction detour, should you find an alternate route or trust the path of bright orange signs?
When it comes to the outbound Liberty Tunnel, which was closed for its first weeknight rush hour Monday afternoon, the answer surprised even PennDOT: Stick with the detour.
The experiment ran like this: Two Pittsburgh Post-Gazette employees set off at 5:51 p.m. from 34 Boulevard of the Allies armed with nothing but stopwatches and almost identical navy blue Dodge Stratuses to settle, with empirical certainty, whether the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation's official detour is the fastest way to 900 Brookline Blvd.
The official detour takes some of the 45,000 motorists who pass through the tunnel on any given day to the McArdle Roadway to Merrimac Street up Mount Washington to Woodruff Street to Route 51.
At nearly 17 minutes just to make it up Mount Washington on Monday afternoon, the detour may seem like a foolhardy gamble.
So when PennDOT spokesman Steve Cowan said drivers should try alternate routes to relieve congestion, it was decided to test that suggestion.
The Post-Gazette devised an alternative to the detour based on advice from an employee with years of experience driving in the South Hills. Take East Carson Street to snake up Becks Run Road to Brownsville Road and finally, Brookline Boulevard -- an 8-mile journey, 1 mile longer than the detour.
And although the detour appeared to produce more frustrated drivers -- one woman could be seen banging her head against her steering wheel on Woodruff Street -- at 34 minutes, 16.4 seconds, the detour was almost six minutes faster than the alternate route.
"This is a big mess," said one woman driving to Pleasant Hills along the alternate route in her white Subaru.
She commiserated in the traffic past SouthSide Works on East Carson Street, the most congested leg of the journey. "I don't know what other way to go," she said.
The 5-mile ride back through the inbound tunnel took just 12 minutes, 35.8 seconds.
When told the PennDOT detour was faster than the alternate route, Mr. Cowan said, "I'm actually a bit surprised by that. I'll have to bring that to [our project managers' and consultants'] attention."
And even though the detour may still be an annoyance, there isn't an alternative construction schedule that could work.
"This work has to be done now, there's no other time frame that can accommodate this work," Mr. Cowan said, citing University of Pittsburgh and Steelers football games at Heinz Field and the start of the school year (at least one school bus route goes through the tunnel). "We don't want to impact those major events. This work needs to be done in August."
The tunnel is being closed to renovate the concrete arches at both ends and the ventilation shaft in the middle of the tunnel.
The outbound Liberty Tunnel will be closed continuously until 6 a.m. Aug. 11. During that time, the inbound tunnel will close daily between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.
The inbound Liberty Tunnel will then close continuously on Aug. 14 at 10 p.m. and will reopen Aug. 30 at 6 a.m., while the outbound tunnel will close each night.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.