The Legislature has approved a measure stripping the Port Authority of its power to regulate transportation services in Allegheny County, transferring it to the state's Public Utility Commission.
Supporters of the measure, sponsored by House Majority Leader Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods, said it will end the Port Authority's "monopoly" on providing transit service in the county.
"By allowing other transportation agencies to offer services, the people will be far better served," Mr. Turzai said in a news release after the Senate approved the bill in a 27-21 vote. "Eliminating the transit monopoly is a win-win for taxpayers and transit riders."
The bill was passed earlier by the House and now awaits Gov. Tom Corbett's approval. He will sign it, spokeswoman Kelli Roberts said.
The Port Authority said it had no objection to the legislation. "We're in favor of anything that improves transportation services in Allegheny County," spokesman Jim Ritchie said.
Whether the bill will inspire other operators to compete with the Port Authority remains to be seen. Private operators have always been free to propose transit service in the county, with approval by the authority. Seven operators have applied since 2006 to operate shuttles, paratransit or mass transit, and the authority has approved every one.
When Lenzner Coach Lines applied to offer service along two discontinued Port Authority routes in March 2011, the authority board approved the request within a month -- much faster than similar actions take when filed with the PUC. The state commission approved four applications from transportation carriers at its May 24 meeting, all of which had been pending for at least three months.
Lenzner has had mixed success in its transit venture. It offered service along the 13J Franklin Park Express and 13K Marshall Express routes after the Port Authority eliminated them as part of a 15 percent service reduction. Lenzner abandoned the Franklin Park route after about eight months because of low ridership.
The other route, which offers five weekday round trips from Marshall, has seen ridership grow from an average of 172 daily riders in October to 271 daily riders in April. The old 13K had average daily ridership of 750 to 800. Lenzner's $5 and $5.25 one-way fares are considerably higher than the Port Authority's $3.25 Zone 2 fare (which is going to $3.75 in July).
Charles Lenzner, the company president, said he would like to offer service on other routes if the authority is forced to go ahead with a 35 percent service cut that is planned in September. He said he has had no problems dealing with Port Authority, and doubted that shifting regulatory power to the PUC would make it any easier for private companies to start transit service.
"They control the cab business," he said of the PUC. "What good has that done?"
State Rep. Paul Costa, D-Wilkins, who voted against the legislation, said he was concerned that private operators might "pick off" the profitable routes, compounding Port Authority's financial problems. He noted that the authority was created in the first place because the region's private bus companies were going bankrupt.
Rep. Mark Mustio, R-Moon, a prime sponsor, said he hoped the legislation would create new options for transit riders, especially those displaced by Port Authority service cuts.
"I'm hoping that the free market will create some opportunities [and] the market will be able to fill that demand," he said. Riders "want a bus. They don't care if it's a Port Authority bus."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.