Like many drivers who arrive at crowded Port Authority park-n-ride lots after all the spaces are taken, Michelle Kotlinski of Richland sometimes makes one up, leaving her car at the end of a row outside of the marked spots in the lot on Perrysville Avenue in Ross.

She said she's careful to avoid blocking other vehicles or obstructing travel lanes.

The same thing happens daily at overstuffed park-n-ride lots from Washington Junction in Bethel Park to Carnegie to the Alpine Village in Monroeville. And most of the time, it's not a major problem.

But on Wednesday, when she returned to her car, Ms. Kotlinski found a $96 illegal parking citation on the windshield. So much for saving money by taking the bus.

Advertise with us

She disputed the officer's notation on the ticket: "vehicle impeded traffic flow through parking lot."

"Where my car was parked, cars could still get around," she said. "It absolutely did not impede traffic."

She took photos to back up her argument.

Port Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie said police typically issue citations only in response to complaints that vehicles are blocking a driving lane or another vehicle, or parked so close that another driver can't open his door.

When that happens, "our police respond to the complaint and issue citations to anyone not parked in a designated spot," he said. "Then, the police generally follow up by patrolling the lot at some time following the complaint to make sure the problems are not continuing."

Advertise with us

He said police have cited only eight drivers at the Ross lot in the past two months and typically issue about 10 to 12 citations a month there.

"I'll also note that we get complaints from [park-n-ride] users telling us that we need to be more proactive in this regard because of the individuals who do not use the marked spaces. Users do not like to be blocked in or when others park too close to their vehicles. They want our police to patrol the lots daily," he said, something that can't be done with more than 50 lots in the system.

Although enforcement is primarily left to the authority's police department, Carnegie police will sometimes issue citations to violators in the park-n-ride next to the borough building, which serves West Busway riders. The lot's capacity is listed at 215 vehicles but on any given weekday several more crowd into every available nook.

Darlene Pfeffer, the borough's police secretary, said Carnegie officers will issue citations "only if there is an obstruction issue." Emergency vehicles sometimes pass through the lot while responding to calls. The borough does not blanket-ticket all offenders in the lot, she said. Primary enforcement rests with Port Authority.

The problem is an outgrowth of park-n-ride's popularity, particularly along busways and the Light Rail Transit system. Many lots fill to capacity by 7 a.m. The Port Authority has long expressed its desire to open more lots, but it cannot afford to enter expensive leases for private property. And some communities have resisted them.

Advertise with us

Things are likely to get worse. If bus service cuts planned for September are implemented, the authority expects to close 18 park-n-ride lots with more than 2,900 spaces. Forty-six bus routes would be eliminated, increasing the number of riders who must drive to reach a stop.

The biggest to close would be the 600-space lot on University Boulevard in Moon. It is served by the G3 Moon Flyer, which would be eliminated. That likely would increase demand at the Carnegie lot. Also slated for closing in September are the 245-space Alpine Village lot and the 100-space lot at Holiday Park Volunteer Fire Department in Plum, both of which reach their capacity daily.