Could a squabble over an expensive expansion project at Philadelphia International Airport prompt US Airways to add more flights in Pittsburgh?
Some local leaders figure it doesn't hurt to ask.
The fight between US Airways and Philadelphia officials over the multibillion-dollar expansion, including construction of a new runway, has some local political and airport officials wondering whether it could be an opening to entice the airline to move flights to Pittsburgh, a city US Airways dropped as a connecting hub in 2004.
"It's something to take a look at," said county Executive Rich Fitzgerald. "I think that if there are issues at any airport in the country where airlines aren't happy, maybe we can provide the service and amenities to be helpful."
Bradley D. Penrod, executive director of the Allegheny County Airport Authority, which runs Pittsburgh International Airport, said he emailed officials at US Airways, Southwest Airlines and other carriers moments after reading a report in the Philadelphia Inquirer earlier this week about the battle over the Philadelphia expansion.
While he did not brazenly offer the airlines space if things didn't work out in the City of Brotherly Love, he did point out what he thought were some of the advantages of doing business in Pittsburgh: lots of capacity and stable costs.
"We know what we can offer," he said. "The airlines will make decisions on what they think is right for the longevity of the company."
In protesting the Philadelphia expansion, US Airways argued the runway project, estimated at $1.8 billion to $3 billion, would increase its cost per boarding passenger from $9.98 to $19.08 by 2018 and to $28.52 by 2025. The airline said the higher costs could force it to reduce service because it no longer would have a competitive advantage in Philadelphia. About 55 percent of the US Airways traffic at the airport is connecting traffic.
US Airways spokesman Todd Lehmacher said cutting service is "definitely a possibility," particularly for flights that are only marginally profitable.
But whether that translates into moving flights to other airports is far from certain.
"I don't think we're at the point where we're talking about moving flights anywhere," Mr. Lehmacher said. "It could mean a reduction in flying long-term in Philadelphia. What we would do with those [unused] assets is still to be determined."
High costs were a major reason given by US Airways for abandoning its Pittsburgh hub. The airport's cost per passenger, currently at $14.80, has been considered among the highest in the country. To some degree, the calculation is related to how busy the airport is. The more travelers that pass through the airport, the lower the cost per passenger. The cost spiked dramatically after US Airways slashed hundreds of flights over the past decade and shifted connecting traffic to Philadelphia and Charlotte.
While the airport's costs have been high, Mr. Penrod said they are declining and will drop significantly in 2018, perhaps to $7 or $8, when the debt from the construction of the $1 billion midfield terminal is paid off.
That could be appealing to US Airways or another carrier, he added, particularly at a time when airlines are focused on cost controls and capacity discipline.
While Mr. Penrod has not heard back from US Airways or the other airlines he emailed, he plans to reach out to them again. He also expects the Philadelphia situation to be a topic of discussion at today's airport authority board meeting.
Mr. Fitzgerald, who took office this month, said he wants to make increasing flights from half-empty Pittsburgh International one of the priorities of his administration.
"If we think there's an opportunity for any airline, we're going to pursue that," he said.
Mr. Lehmacher said any talk of moving flights to Pittsburgh is "hypothetical" and that US Airways is "committed to working with our partners here in Philadelphia in reaching consensus on the expansion."
William Lauer, a local airline analyst, said Philadelphia has always been a large local market for US Airways, but also has posed major challenges because of congestion, weather problems and less than ideal facilities.
Nonetheless, he doubts that US Airways would look to move flights elsewhere if it doesn't get its way on the expansion, noting that there are huge expenses involved in taking down hubs and re-establishing a base elsewhere.
If local political and airport leaders want to be rooting for something, perhaps it should be a merger between US Airways and bankrupt American Airlines.
That, Mr. Lauer argued, has the potential to bring more flights to Pittsburgh. American, he said, already has a strong presence in New York and Boston, meaning that Philadelphia could be de-emphasized.
That, in turn, could open the door for Pittsburgh to get more traffic.
"I think there could be some benefit, some significant benefit, but it would unlikely be a one-for-one match," he said.
The battle between US Airways and Philadelphia officials came amid speculation that the airline was considering a mini-hub in Pittsburgh.
That's not the case, Mr. Lehmacher said.
"There is no truth to the rumors. US Airways is focused on our four core cities," he said, referring to Philadelphia, Charlotte, Phoenix and Washington, D.C.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.