When the water taxi Miss Pittsburgh took to the rivers in 1999, it could carry as many as 72 passengers. But that number has been reduced to 42, and it isn't because Miss Pittsburgh is getting older.
It's because we've gotten fatter.
The Coast Guard last month implemented new regulations that require passenger boat operators across the U.S. to recalculate the capacities of their vessels using an "assumed average weight" of 185 pounds per passenger, replacing a 140-pound standard that was put in place a few billion Big Macs ago.
"The whole premise of it is that we as Americans are getting heavier," said Lt. John Downing, chief of the Coast Guard's inspection division here. "When passengers weigh more, the stability of the vessel has the possibility of being compromised."
How much heavier are we? According to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average weight of men ages 20 to 74 has increased from about 166 pounds in 1960 to nearly 195 pounds now. Before any women start snickering, let it be said that they, too, have appreciated in size, from an average 140 pounds to nearly 165.
About one-third of American adults and nearly 1 in 5 children are now considered obese, and health care professionals routinely describe it as an epidemic.
For Mark Schiller, captain of Miss Pittsburgh and co-owner of Pittsburgh Cruise Lines and Pittsburgh Water Limo, the impact of the new regulations came quickly. He estimated that he lost $800 of water taxi business for each of the three Steelers home games in December because of his boat's lowered capacity.
He already had trimmed the boat's limit to 49 passengers voluntarily, as suggested by the Coast Guard years ago when it began to study changes to the regulations. As of Dec. 1, he lost another 10 seats, meaning his new maximum is 39 passengers and three crew members.
His only option to challenge the reduction, he said, is a costly stability test, with no guarantee of a positive outcome.
"We agree with safety first in all aspects of the business and the [former] average weight per person in the U.S. was much too low," he said. But he said the regulations stemmed from two deadly accidents that he believes were caused by pilot carelessness, not passenger weight.
A tour boat capsized in Lake George, N.Y., in 2005, killing 20 elderly passengers. Five died when a water taxi sank in Baltimore Harbor in 2004 amid 50-mph winds, and the investigation concluded that the boat carried too much weight -- even though it complied with the Coast Guard's 140-pound standard at the time.
The National Transportation Safety Board warned in December 2004 that the standard was too low. Writing and implementing new regulations, always a ponderous process, has taken since then.
The new rules also apply to the Gateway Clipper Fleet, the "green" educational boat Explorer and the six amphibious vessels operated by Just Ducky Tours.
Terry Wirginis, Gateway Clipper president, said the company spent about $10,000 to have naval architects do sophisticated stability testing of its five vessels. All were certified to keep their existing capacities.
Mr. Wirginis said the capacity of the smallest boat, Countess, was reduced from 150 to 112 prior to the certification process because the company decided the available space was too small for the larger crowds.
"I am comfortable that for the vast majority of the U.S. fleet under Coast Guard regulation, it's not going to have a major impact," he said.
Just Ducky Tours is working with the Coast Guard and naval architects to determine whether it needs to change the capacity of its DUKW amphibious trucks, which were built during World War II to carry supplies and troops over land and water. Now the vehicles are used for a combination land-river tour of the Golden Triangle. Generally, the vehicles take 30 passengers, co-owner Chris D'Addario said.
"We've always done stability testing with the Coast Guard (at the lower 140-pound threshold) and there's never been an issue," he said. He noted that the vessels survived eight-foot seas during the war, a much tougher test than what Pittsburgh's rivers offer.
The company has until April, when it resumes tours, to determine whether to reduce capacity. "I don't think it will have a serious impact," Mr. D'Addario said.
He said he understands the reason for the new regulations. "We're all getting bigger in different ways, whether it's muscle mass or gaining weight by making bad food choices," he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.