Jerry Sandusky’s defense team is withdrawing its claim that one of the former Penn State football assistant’s sexual abuse victims has disavowed his prior 2012 trial testimony.
But that’s not a surrender, a Sandusky supporter said Friday.
Rather, it’s a strategic move designed to help the defense team revive its broader, multi-issue case faster, and quite possibly in federal court.
As a result, the scope of a scheduled Tuesday hearing in Bellefonte, Pa., where Ryan Rittmeyer, once known as Victim 10, was to take the stand, has changed dramatically.
Instead of taking testimony on Rittmeyer’s recantation and new assertions that he was improperly coached by police and prosecutors on what to say in the original trial, the hearing will now involve a Q&A with Sandusky himself.
Senior Judge Maureen Skerda, of Warren County, said she will question Sandusky, testifying remotely from state prison, to confirm Sandusky understands what withdrawing this claim means for his case.
Sandusky’s attorneys did not respond to requests for comment after Skerda’s revised order posted Friday.
But Frank Parlato Jr., the investigator credited with securing Rittmeyer’s recantation, said Friday it is more a strategic move than a surrender.
By sacrificing Rittmeyer’s claim, Parlato explained, the defense will be able to move directly to an appellate court review.
That, in turn, can eventually get the case into federal court more quickly where, Parlato believes, Sandusky is more likely to get a fair review.
Parlato stressed Friday he isn’t speaking for Sandusky’s attorneys and he doesn’t mean to impugn any specific judge.
But the reality is, he continued, Pennsylvania’s state courts are “so invested in this conviction and the publicity damage that could be caused by a reversal that it may take a different venue to have the temerity to look at it without any consideration of that backlash.”
The record may be a little more nuanced than that.
In the related Penn State cover-up case, a Superior Court panel threw out the most serious charges against former Penn State President Graham Spanier and two top aides based on what it found to be improper grand jury procedures.
Spanier, former Penn State Athletic Director Tim Curley and former Senior Vice President for Business and Finance Gary Schultz were ultimately convicted of single misdemeanor counts of child endangerment for not acting on then-graduate assistant Mike McQueary’s credible 2001 complaint about Sandusky.
Sandusky himself, however, has lost all his appeals at every level in Pennsylvania.
The defendant’s age, 82, Parlato added, makes time a real factor too.
By pulling the plug on the Rittmeyer case, the defense can save several months of time waiting for Skerda’s evaluation and decision, which might have applied only to the Victim 10 convictions anyway, Parlato said.
Sandusky’s 30-year minimum prison term is based on more than 40 convictions on charges that he serially sexually abused 10 different boys between 1994 and 2009.
State prosecutors in Attorney General Dave Sunday’s office did not respond to messages left on Friday, instead saying they would stand on their latest legal filing.
In that entry, the prosecutors asked Skerda to proceed with the full hearing, noting in part they had “extensive rebuttal evidence and witnesses” that they hoped to present.
At a minimum, the prosecution argued, Skerda should conduct the interview with Sandusky.
“There should be a record of defendant informing the court that he has discussed withdrawing the claim with counsel, that he understands the consequences of that, and that he agrees with that decision,” prosecutors Cari Mahler and Jaime Keating wrote.
After a closed telephone conference with the attorney Friday, that’s what Skerda decided to do.
Among the issues in the broader post-conviction appeals that the defense hopes to resurrect are:
• Claims that multiple victims in Sandusky’s case were driven by the prospect of large civil settlements and allowed themselves to be coached by police, counselors and civil attorneys to stack stories that painted Sandusky — once one of legendary Penn State head coach Joe Paterno’s top lieutenants — as a master groomer and serial predator.
• Allegations that two of the lead prosecutors later profited off a civil settlement reached between Penn State and one of the criminal case victims, putting into question their own motivation for pursuing the case.
• A claim that Sandusky’s jury was tainted because one of the 12 panel members had been interviewed by Penn State’s internal investigators prior to the trial.
In past arguments on Sandusky’s appeals, however, prosecutors have criticized the defense for drawing conclusions from cherry-picked excerpts of police statements and testimony transcripts, with no context from body language, demeanor or tone of voice — all of which the jury saw live in reaching its guilty verdicts.
Prosecutors’ initial case against Sandusky also had other types of evidence, including McQueary’s report to Paterno about the 2001 incident he witnessed between Sandusky and an unidentified child in a Penn State shower; a 1998 case that was reported to Penn State police and dropped without charges after investigation; and a Penn State janitor’s account — relayed to jurors secondhand — of an undated after-hours molestation he walked in on in 2000.
The Sandusky case rocked Penn State and the broader college football world, given Sandusky’s prominence in the beloved Paterno’s firmament.
The firestorm after Sandusky’s November 2011 arrest quickly cost Paterno — who notched more wins as a collegiate head coach than any other — his job, and led to Spanier’s resignation under pressure.
It also, albeit less directly, contributed to a dramatic reshaping of the college football landscape, as major football schools rebelled against what they saw as the NCAA’s dramatic assertion of new powers in the Penn State case.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.