A court panel has criticized the highest-ranking federal judge in central Pennsylvania over his attempts to be witty in a court opinion he wrote for a case filed over the tragic deaths of two children.
The Third Circuit, which hears federal appeals from Pennsylvania, upheld the Dec. 7, 2023, opinion from Chief Justice Matthew Brann.
But in a footnote on the opinion, it scolded him for the “inappropriate attempted witticisms” in relation to a Oct. 20, 2019, crash.
Neither Brann nor a court spokesperson returned PennLive’s requests for comment.
The lawsuit stems from a 2019 fatal vehicle crash on Route 17 in Tioga County, N.Y.
A deer collision disabled Darelene Allen’s Mitsubishi Mirage before a tractor trailer behind Allen “violently collided” with the car, killing the two children.
“Unfortunately, despite its name, Ms. Allen’s [Mitsubishi] Mirage was no optical illusion …” Bran wrote in his 2023 opinion.
He later went on, saying, “... after consulting its crystal ball, the Court foresees the parties filing motions … on the eve of trial consistent with the objections they raised in their briefing."
In the 2023 opinion, Brann granted summary judgment in favor of Gateway Freight Systems Inc., one of the defendants. He also excluded expert testimony that Robert Allen, the children’s father, tried to bring into the case.
Robert Allen, administering the children’s estate, appealed that opinion to the Third Circuit, leading to the panel’s opinion published Tuesday.
That panel backed Brann’s legal decisions as sound but criticized the comments as inappropriate.
“We are deeply sympathetic to the loss of two young lives, and we have no reason to doubt that the district judge shared our concern,” the Third Circuit wrote in its opinion.
It continued in its footnote:
“These attempts at wit are inappropriate given the circumstances of this dispute. We do not doubt that the jurist who decided this case gave it the serious attention that it deserved. ... But such misguided and ill-conceived attempts at levity could be misinterpreted by others — especially by those in the general public — and lead them to conclude that the opinion is something other than the thorough and well-reasoned opinion we consider it to be.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.