HARRISBURG — A pair of lawmakers has unveiled plans for legislation that would target expanded tax relief to low-income and middle class property owners by tying the relief to the share of income devoted to property tax.
The idea of the so-called circuit breaker is to direct assistance to those who most need assistance dealing with the burden of property taxes, said Rep. Robert Freeman, D-Northampton.
“It seems that nearly every year, property taxes go up and the bills get more difficult to pay for many families and especially older Pennsylvanians on a fixed income who are struggling to stay in their homes,” Mr. Freeman said. “This proposal would offer Pennsylvania homeowners needed property tax relief and build fairness into the property tax system by capping property taxes to reflect household income.”
While broader efforts to eliminate property taxes have been stymied by the daunting challenge of finding an alternative that will replace the billions in tax revenue generated by property tax, the circuit breaker sets the more modest goal of getting a property tax break to those who need it most, Mr. Freeman said.
Pennsylvania’s current system of generating much of the revenue for schools through local property taxes is considered “regressive” because it forces poorer property owners to devote a larger share of their income toward tax payments than more wealthy property owners.
Even so, the details of exactly how that circuit breaker would deliver relief hasn’t been spelled out yet.
Legislation introduced by Mr. Freeman and Sen. Jimmy Dillon, D-Philadelphia, would call for a change to the state Constitution to allow for the implementation of a circuit breaker on property tax. Constitutional change ballot questions must be approved by lawmakers in two consecutive legislative sessions.
Enabling legislation that would be passed by the General Assembly if voters approve that Constitutional change would define how that tax relief would be delivered, Mr. Freeman said. But one of the more common approaches used in other states with such circuit breakers would be to deliver the relief in the form of a tax credit given to the qualifying homeowners when they file their state income taxes.
Mr. Dillon said the circuit breaker would deliver “desperately needed relief” for low-income homeowners and help address the problem of housing affordability.
“A property tax circuit breaker will help stabilize neighborhoods and communities across the commonwealth. By reducing the tax burden, more Pennsylvanians can purchase and maintain family homes,” he said.
The idea of the circuit breaker isn’t new – 17 other states, including New York, have some sort of circuit breaker mechanism.
In New York's program (which carried a $382 million price tag in 2021), homeowners qualify for the circuit breaker relief if they spend more than 6% of their income on property taxes, and make less than $250,000 in income. Credits are given worth up to 14% of the remaining property tax obligation, depending on income. Credits will be between $250 and $350. About 1-in-4 property owners got the tax credit generated by New York’s circuit breaker.
Both lawmakers introduced circuit breaker bills on Tuesday. Mr. Freeman’s bill, House Bill 656, was referred to the Finance Committee. Mr. Dillon’s bill, Senate Bill 635, has not been assigned to a committee yet, according to the Legislature’s website.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.