Debra Todd has officially forged a new title in the country’s oldest appellate court and the Commonwealth’s highest court: Madame Chief Justice.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Chief Justice Todd was formally installed in a ceremony Friday afternoon in Pittsburgh. Dozens, including local policymakers and university representatives, gathered in the ornate Omni William Penn ballroom Downtown to watch the historic ceremony.

“There was a book published in 2004 entitled, ‘Nice girls don’t get the corner office,’” she said. “Well, as the newly installed chief justice of Pennsylvania, I can tell you nice girls do get the corner office.”

During the ceremony, the soon-to-be chief justice sat among her fellow justices and an emeritus chief justice, Thomas G. Saylor, who gave the opening remarks.

Advertise with us

“This occasion is especially momentous as she becomes the first woman to occupy this high office in the court’s long history,” he said.

That history is 300 years old.

Chief Justice Todd, the daughter of a steelworker who grew up in Ellwood City, actually has been serving for months as the top-ranking jurist. Chief Justice Max Baer’s death in late September elevated her to the court’s top spot because she had served longer than any of her colleagues.

Baer was planning to retire in December and, as the justice with the longest continuous service, Chief Justice Todd knew she would be taking his place. The chief justice not only hears cases and writes opinions with the six other justices, but also supervises and oversees operations for the entire Pennsylvania judicial system.

Just three days after she administered the oath of office to Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro, he was able to share in her special day Friday, highlighting her roots and “steelworker sensibility.”

Advertise with us

“I am proud to be here today with Madame Chief Justice, fittingly to be not in our state capitol, but in Madame Chief Justice’s hometown,” Mr. Shapiro said.

“A graduate of Chatham College and later the University of Pittsburgh Law School, she is Western Pennsylvania through and through. A hard worker. A fighter. She is a distinguished public servant who has made Pennsylvania better through her wisdom and leadership, and most importantly, her heart. She really cares.”

A Democrat, Chief Justice Todd was elected to the high court in 2007 after eight years on Superior Court, where she handled civil and criminal appeals from county courts. The 65-year-old graduated from Pitt Law, and she worked as a lawyer for 18 years, including five years as a litigator for USX Corp. Her current term on the high court ends Jan. 3, 2028

Chief Justice Todd lives in Pittsburgh and has three children, including her daughter Alexandra, who expressed her pride for her “idol and hero” during the ceremony. Alexandra reminisced about the earlier days of her mother’s career when, at age 5, she would help her father put up signs for Chief Justice Todd’s campaigns.

“It has all been worth it to watch her shine today,” Alexandra Todd said. “I can say that Pennsylvania is in perfect hands. I love you, Mom, I’m so proud.”

Advertise with us

Chief Justice Todd took off her glasses several times to wipe away tears as her daughter spoke, later exclaiming, “I said I wasn’t gonna cry!”

Andrew Masich, president and CEO of the Senator John Heinz History Center, took to the microphone to provide some historical context on the significance of the day.

“Today, 30% of Pennsylvania's active judges are women,” he said. “Astoundingly, 71% of the Superior Court judges and 67% of the Commonwealth Court judges are men. It’s hard to even imagine the trials and tribulations overcome by these pioneer women.”

Mary Jane Bowes, president of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law Alumni Association and a former colleague of the chief justice, recalled how her friend excelled in academics and how grateful she was that the jurist chose Pitt to start her legal career.

“We encourage our students to apply themselves diligently to the study of law, to evince the highest values of integrity and professionalism and to find their unique role in advancing the cause of justice,” she said. “Debra Todd has done all that.”

Advertise with us

The justice’s husband, Steve, joined her at the front of the room for the swearing in, with Alexandra holding the family Bible. Before administrating the oath, Justice Christine Donahue said she had just one other historical note to highlight.

“This is the first time in Pennsylvania history that a proud daughter of a steelworker is being sworn into office as Chief Justice of Pennsylvania by the proud daughter of a coal miner,” Justice Donohue said, adapting a statement that then-Justice Todd made when she swore in Justice Donohue in 2016.

After reciting the oath, a smiling chief justice first shook the hand of her fellow justice before hugging her family to cheers and applause.

The ceremony concluded with Madame Chief Justice sharing advice to young women who want to become lawyers.

“Years ago, the law profession was a man’s world,” she said. “Thankfully, that has changed. Women are law firm partners, general counsel, judges and Supreme Court justices.

“But in striving for success, there is no reason than to be anything other than who you are in what is admittingly a tough profession, where assertiveness and tenacity reign supreme.”