In his second visit in only a week-and-a-half to a state he says could single-handedly determine the success of his re-election bid, President Donald Trump told supporters in Erie on Tuesday that the reason their county swung red four years ago — because Pennsylvania voters wanted to oust the “depraved political establishment” and elect an “outsider” — should motivate them to vote for him again.

This time, the establishment is Democrat Joe Biden, Mr. Trump said — who’s the kind of politician that, if he had done his job over the years, wouldn’t have forced a traditionally blue county like Erie to seek political upheaval.

“He was here for eight years as vice president and 47 years-plus as a politician in Washington, and he’s always like, ‘Why didn’t [Trump] do this?’” Mr. Trump said. “Why the hell didn’t [Mr. Biden] do it?”

By warning voters that Mr. Biden’s history of “one cruel betrayal after another” at the expense of the working class will only continue if elected president in two weeks, Mr. Trump is hoping to convince Pennsylvanians that they shouldn’t betray him.

Advertise with us

Polls have consistently shown Mr. Biden with a moderate lead, as Democrats continue to make the case — like Mr. Trump did in 2016 — that political leaders have left places like Erie behind, and that they’re the ones who will stand up for working families. It’s an argument that’s been at the center of the presidential race and will likely continue during Thursday night’s final presidential debate.

While Mr. Trump alleged that Pennsylvania knows better than any state that his Democratic opponent has been “outsourcing your jobs, offshoring your factories and selling out the American worker” for decades, Mr. Biden said Pennsylvania has been failed by this president and that Mr. Trump broke his promise to bring back jobs to Erie.

“He failed working Pennsylvanians by incentivizing companies to offshore jobs, waging war on unions, and giving huge tax breaks to big corporations and the ultra-wealthy,” Mr. Biden said in a statement.

Between boasts of economic success and how he remembered the once-”forgotten” men and women, Mr. Trump’s speech, like most of them recently, was full of warnings about a hypothetical Biden administration: that the former vice president would dissolve America’s borders, “dismantle” police departments, “terminate” religious liberty and “destroy” the suburbs.

But his main warning — similar to when he spoke in Johnstown last week — was about the survival of fracking if Mr. Biden is elected.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trump claimed again that Mr. Biden would ban fracking and abolish Pennsylvania’s energy industry, and used a video montage — something he’s never done — that showed many of the Democrat’s past statements on the issue.

Mr. Biden has insisted that his plan calls for an end to new oil and gas drilling permits on federal land — while the majority of fracking in Pennsylvania is done on private land.

“If Biden is elected, he will wipe out your energy industry ... just like he wiped out your steel industry and I brought it back,” Mr. Trump said after the video ended.

The solution? Look to Mr. Trump as the savior, he said.

But to Pennsylvania state Rep. Bob Merski, D-Erie, Mr. Trump has only saved people on Wall Street during his first term, not the people of Erie.

Advertise with us

“When the stock market’s doing well and it’s disconnected from the everyday lives of Americans — we have a huge problem,” Mr. Merski said in a call with Pennsylvania Democrats early Tuesday. “And this is a modern problem that we haven’t seen. Usually, the stock market has gone up when jobs have gone up, and we’re not seeing that right now in places like Erie, Pennsylvania.”

Mr. Trump nonetheless accused Mr. Biden of making a “corrupt bargain” with his party in exchange for the presidency, and claimed he’s handed control over to socialists and left-wing extremists who are “full of hate and rage and scorn for the middle class and for everybody.”

The president painted Democrats as elitists, eager to take away guns while enjoying private security, and letting drugs and crime flow into communities while they live in gated compounds.

“It’s time to send a message to these wealthy liberal hypocrites by delivering Joe Biden, Sleepy Joe, a thundering defeat on Nov. 3,” Mr. Trump said. “You’ve got to get out and vote.”

Mr. Biden, in a message of his own, said working families in Erie — with whom he met earlier this month while touring a plumbers union facility — “deserve a president who will fight for them on day one.”

Advertise with us

“As president, I will help Pennsylvanians recover from four years of neglect and put working families at the center of our effort to build the economy back better than it was before,” Mr. Biden said.

Mr. Trump, too, said he’d build the economy back — but from COVID-19. He said next year will be the greatest economic year in U.S. history, and he praised his administration’s handling of the virus — which he said has saved millions of lives.

Mr. Trump said his administration pioneered “incredible therapies,” reduced the fatality rate 85% and is working to “make the antibody treatment that I received, available to anybody that needs it, free.”

“It’s getting very close to getting approved,” Mr. Trump said. “We will have 100 million vaccine doses before the end of the year, maybe sooner than that, maybe substantially before.”

Mr. Biden’s assessment of the Trump administration’s COVID response was far less positive. He said the president “failed Pennsylvania families by intentionally misleading them about the severity of COVID-19,” which resulted in nearly 8,500 Pennsylvanians dying and hundreds of thousands of people losing their livelihoods.

Advertise with us

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.