Centre County’s district attorney, armed with a new grand jury report on drinking, hazing and Greek life at Penn State University, delivered a scathing assessment Friday regarding university oversight of a system that in February saw the death of Timothy Piazza.

Stacy Parks Miller detailed results of the grand jury’s 10-month investigation at a morning news conference. She suggested the horrifying events inside the Beta Theta Pi house that led to the death of Mr. Piazza, 19, a sophomore pledge, should not have been a surprise given other incidents at Penn State fraternities in recent years.

She called self-policing by fraternities “a joke and a catastrophe” and that “Penn State either did not know, did not care to know or turned a blind eye,” to fight clubs, binge drinking and various “sadistic” initiation rituals over the years at other fraternities, which were uncovered by the grand jury investigation.

The resulting 236-page report offered varied recommendations, including that the state Legislature toughen the law for hazing, which is now a misdemeanor, but should be as severe as a first-degree felony when it leads to a death, the panel suggested.

Advertise with us

It also said all university employees should become mandatory reporters of hazing.

In a 70-page response to the grand jury document, Penn State disputed characterizations that it was aware of drinking problems on campus and did not try to address them. It alluded to recent efforts to tighten controls on drinking and other behaviors, penalize fraternities and overhaul policies.

The university, through its law firm Duane Morris, said it "has made extraordinary efforts, and shown an unwavering commitment to promoting safety and accountability and aligning the values and behaviors of the Greek system organizations with the expectations of the university."

Saying it had only been allowed to see part of the grand jury report prior to its release, Penn State and its President Eric Barron issued an additional statement on Friday afternoon mourning Mr. Piazza's passing, and pointing to reforms for a broken Greek self-governance system, including measures not tried elsewhere.

It said Penn State remains committed to turning the "anguish of this tragedy into reforms" but also expressed disappointment with the report's conclusions, noting "it is not a solution to simply point an accusatory finger."

Advertise with us

During the news conference, Rich Braham, father of a Penn State Altoona student who died by suicide after hazing, said “No one should die because they want to join a fraternity.”

Ms. Parks Miller said the grand jury found a system in which the university abdicated responsibility for policing dozens of fraternities, many with a history of violations, to the Inter-fraternity Council. That body is made up individuals who themselves were part of the Greek system.

“Penn State allowed those students to police themselves and the results were absolutely predictable,” she said.

“There was no system,” she said. “Penn State was literally saying, ‘Go ahead IFC. We won’t look.’”

She described a woefully inadequate infrastructure for spotting and recording excessive alcohol consumption, underage drinking and other offenses at fraternity events. Records of enforcement often were not kept, as was the case when Mr. Piazza, an engineering student from Lebanon, N.J., died after a night of forced drinking during a hazing ritual, she said.

Advertise with us

As one example, she said, outside checkers hired by the IFC to make “spot checks” of fraternity houses during parties were limited in what infractions they looked for and were not allowed to enter the home until fraternity leadership came to the door.

It enabled evidence to be hidden, Ms. Parks Miller said.

Ms. Parks Miller referred to an earlier instance in which the Beta Theta Pi national organization suspended the chapter. “Penn State allowed them to re-open a year later without any investigation,” she said.

“The grand jury just could not understand these contradictions.”

The university long maintained that it had no control over the IFC oversight because Greek organizations were separate from the university, Ms. Parks Miller said.

Advertise with us

But that clearly was not the case given that the university or its employees were intimately involved, from holding funds to promoting the organizations on its web site, she asserted.

“It’s not separate. They’re not separate at all,” she said. “They aren’t powerless.”

She said it’s clear, because, “Tim died and they took complete control of it. There’s your proof.”

Mr. Piazza’s death -- and the subsequent prosecutions -- triggered intense media coverage. As the year went on, the case became part of a widening national discussion on Greek life as other universities from Ohio to Florida sanctioned or suspended Greek systems following incidents on their campuses.

In May, an earlier grand jury presentment in Mr. Piazza’s death chronicled the events in the fraternity house just off the University Park campus. He and 13 other pledges on Feb. 2 were subjected to a forced-drinking ritual called " the gauntlet," moving from location to location and consuming beer, wine and vodka.

Advertise with us

Mr. Piazza, who tumbled down stairs, sustained severe injuries. But he was not transported by ambulance for 12 hours and succumbed to injuries on Feb. 4 in Hershey Medical Center.

Prosecutors initially charged 18 fraternity brothers. But after a multi-day preliminary hearing this summer, a judge in September dismissed the most serious charges including involuntary manslaughter.

The next month, asserting an error in law, Ms. Parks Miller refiled the charges in October, adding charges to an additional 12 fraternity members.

Some of the charges resulted from a video that police say was deleted by a fraternity brother but recovered by investigators with help from the FBI.

Mr. Piazza’s death occurred amid ongoing attempts by Penn State to curb alcohol abuse, sexual misconduct and other problems within the fraternity system. The school has further cracked down and earlier this fall announced disciplinary actions against students in the case.

Advertise with us

Of 32 students that faced discipline, more than half have left the campus.

Penn State, in its response, said the university's efforts to curb alcohol abuse were ignored or dismissed by the grand jury and noted that campus drinking is a pervasive and national issue. It also bemoaned "relatively weak," hazing and underage drinking laws.

"Notwithstanding all this, the report suggests that the university and its officials -- with the weakest 'control' over these organizations (that of University recognition) -- should be expected to solve this problem alone," according to the response.

"That makes no sense. Experts in this field agree there is an obvious need for partnership and cooperation at all levels, if we are to make progress."

The university also pledged to continue to educate, investigate and discipline students involved in drinking.

Advertise with us

"Alcohol abuse and hazing, the governance of private fraternities, and the relationship between law enforcement and the internal disciplinary process confront academic institutions across the country. They are deep rooted and pervasive in our society. There are no easy answers. We welcome thoughtful advice and suggestions. The University is prepared to be a leader, but not a scapegoat."

Donald Gilliland contributed to this report. Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.

Penn State Piazza Grand Jury Report Pdf (PDF)

Penn State Piazza Grand Jury Report Pdf (Text)