ST. STEPHENS, Wyo. — After 130 years, the children have at last come home, returned from silent graves in faraway Pennsylvania to this land of majestic mountains and to a people who have long mourned their passing.
Scores of Northern Arapaho people intended to gather Friday morning to accompany the boys on their final journey, to witness their reburial in the rocky Wyoming soil, to grieve their loss anew, and to celebrate their homecoming.
A much older generation, gone now, bid goodbye to Horse, Little Chief, and Little Plume in 1881, when they were taken across the country to the Carlisle Indian Industrial School, where masters and teachers did all they could to knock the students’ traditions and culture out of them. Within two years, all three were dead.
On Friday morning, a newer generation, people who had listened to the stories and imagined the boys’ terror and suffering so far from home, braced for a day of services and memorials on the Wind River Indian Reservation.
“It is going to be a difficult day, not just for me, but for everyone who has felt the emptiness,” said 19-year-old Josiah Washington. “But it is also going to be a good day. That sense of being incomplete will lessen.”
He and his mother, Olivia Washington, are family to Horse, and both joined the Northern Arapaho delegation that traveled to Carlisle this month as Army forensic experts disinterred the three graves. The excavation followed formal tribal requests for the boys’ repatriation.
Read More
“There are no words that could possibly convey the emotion this has brought me,” said Olivia Washington. “But just knowing that Horse is finally home, to be put to rest with his family and among his people, brings a great comfort and peace.”
Nearly 200 Indian children who died at the school lie in a neat, military-style cemetery on the grounds of what is now the Army War College. A painstaking, trowel-by-trowel dig unearthed three small pine coffins — and shocking news.
Little Plume’s remains were missing. The coffin by his headstone contained the remains of two people, neither of them him. On Thursday, family members here vowed to continue to search for him and to battle for his return.
Horse and Little Chief were identified based on their age and sex.
The cemetery was moved to its current location in 1927, in what American Indian leaders have criticized as a haphazard job.
Little Chief, the eldest son of Chief Sharp Nose, arrived at the school March 11, 1881, only 14 and accompanied by Horse, 11, and Little Plume, 9. Like other students, they were assigned new English names: Little Chief became Dickens Nor, Horse was renamed Horace Washington, and Little Plume was called Hayes Vanderbilt Friday.
The nation’s first federal off-reservation boarding school was designed to “civilize” Indian children by erasing their languages, religions, and family bonds. Braids were cut off, military-style jackets issued. Beatings were a common punishment, and epidemics killed boys and girls weakened by hard labor. At the time, forcing Indians to assimilate into white society was considered a humane alternative to killing them outright.
The Carlisle boarding school model spread through the United States and Canada. Today, some scholars blame the legacy of broken family ties and lost languages for many of the ills that plague modern tribes.
Horse was to be reburied first Friday morning, carried to St. Stephen’s cemetery, where handmade wooden crosses outnumber stone headstones, near a church that has married Catholic and Indian cultures.
Inside the church where Horse’s relatives worship, the altar is a huge drum, central to Indian life, and Jesus Christ is depicted as native, his head graced not by a halo but by a shining white eagle.
Little Chief’s burial will follow at the Sharp Nose cemetery, defined by its rugged sagebrush hills. After final, traditional rites, families and friends will gather for a feast at Blue Sky Hall in Ethete.
For the Northern Arapaho and others, the repatriation of the children is many things — a sign of healing, of hope for the future, of rapprochement with the U.S. government and even with the Army, the chosen instrument of the Indians’ destruction in the 1800s.
Across the country, tribes have been watching to see how this first attempt at Carlisle would fare.
Within days, the family of George El, who died at Carlisle at 17 in 1891, told the Inquirer and Daily News that they wanted his remains returned, and the Oglala Sioux in Pine Ridge, S.D., said they were exploring the recovery of five children. The Rosebud Sioux in South Dakota seek 10 boys and girls, and Alaska tribes may want children, too.
The Wind River Reservation lies just east of the Continental Divide, a tract roughly the combined size of Delaware and Rhode Island. It’s a place where horses romp through luminous green meadows, bighorn sheep tiptoe through mountain crags, and the rivers run sapphire blue.
The deer and antelope don’t actually play, but they do pose traffic hazards.
Both the Northern Arapaho and Eastern Shoshone live here, traditional enemies who in 1878 were forced to share the same land in what the government promised was a temporary arrangement. Today, people work at ranching, at tribal casinos, and at tourist agencies that serve fishermen who come in search of trout.
Here, memory runs deep. Elderly men can recall boarding school cruelties as though they happened yesterday. Through nearby Riverton twists the Sand Creek Massacre Trail, a memorial to the infamous 1864 slaughter in Colorado of peaceful Arapaho and Cheyenne men, women, and children.
Descendants of the survivors still live here. Others here had grandparents or great-grandparents who went to Carlisle, who know the school not just as the alma mater of Jim Thorpe, but as the place where beloved family suffered and sometimes died.
“The Carlisle Indian School grounds is not a good place. You get there, and you can just feel something ‘wrong,’ ” Josiah Washington said as he prepared for Friday morning’s reburials. “Horse has been reunited with his family. He has come home to his people.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.