HARRISBURG — A looming deficit is threatening the state’s ability to protect dogs from abuse and neglect, and two legislators are making an effort to fight for every last dollar before the countdown ends.
The Dog Law Restricted Account, created under then-Gov. Ed Rendell in 2008, acts as the main financial source for the Department of Agriculture’s Bureau of Dog Law Enforcement. The account is facing the prospect of being broke if overhaul of the state’s dog laws doesn’t happen within the next year.
The account was a part of the state’s efforts to revitalize dog law enforcement policies and helped combat the “puppy mill capital of the East” reputation Pennsylvania acquired. Dogs finally had the law by their side to help crack down on poor living conditions that could consume the majority of their lives, such as cramped, stacked cages with wire flooring.
Now, a lack of resources to fund the additional care for these animals has cornered the bureau.
The two pieces of legislation, proposed by Sen. Judith Schwank, D-Berks, and Rep. Eddie Pashinski, D-Luzerne, are making June a promising month for animal rights just as “Libre’s Law,” drafted by Sen. Richard Alloway, R-Adams, which aims to ramp up penalties when an individual is convicted of animal abuse, was passed unanimously in the Senate and now makes its way to the governor’s desk for signing.
The bureau has only one dog warden in each county. The wardens are responsible for inspecting kennels, responding to dangerous dog bites, and protecting stray dogs among other oversight measures — which could all come to an end without more funding.
The situation is “extremely critical,” according to Mr. Pashinski.
“Without either my bill or Sen. Schwank’s bill, the state will not have the resources to continue this work, threatening to undo the progress made over the past nine years and putting dogs and puppies at greater risk of mistreatment,” he said.
That’s why Ms. Schwank and Mr. Pashinski are making cross-chamber efforts to increase the license fees, modernize license registration and reinstate a grant program to local shelters in order to continue the funding to continue the bureau’s efforts.
“The goal is long-term solvency in the Dog Law fund,” Mr. Pashinski said. “We expect that the increases will keep the fund solvent.”
According to Ms. Schwank, this increase in license fees is just a foundation for future changes based on the possible need for more money to finance the bureau’s duties.
“The situation gives me great concern on how we’re going to enforce dog law, inspect and license commercial kennels, protect stray dogs and protect the public if we don’t get additional funding,” Ms. Schwank said. “[The bill] gives the secretary of agriculture the ability to raise the fees as needed.”
Without services that are carried out by the bureau, problems such as the overpopulation of stray animals and abused animals without aid will be a more prominent issue.
“Without more funding, we’re going to have bigger problems in the future, especially in urban areas,” Ms. Schwank said. “This situation is going to be very difficult going forward.”
The Dog Law Restricted Account receives around 85 percent of its finances through dog license fees — one of the only methods by which the bureau collects money to conduct its services. In 2016, the bureau made $6.3 million in dog licensing fees, according to a Department of Agriculture report.
To license a dog, it costs $8.50 for a year or $51.50 for a lifetime license. If the animal is spayed or neutered, the annual fee is $6.50 and the lifetime fee is $31.50.
The bills propose what Ms. Schwank called a “minimal” increase to these fees. If passed, the license fee would be $11 and the lifetime license fee would be $74. If sprayed or neutered, the license fee would be $8 and the lifetime license fee would be $44.
The proposed fees are on par with many other states. But some states, such as Ohio, charge significantly more. In that neighboring state, a one-year fee is $14 and a lifetime fee is $180 — nearly three times more than what the Pennsylvania bill calls for.
Pennsylvania also falls behind other states with a lack of online resources for online license registration.
Even with increased fees and modernizing the registration process, the question remains whether these efforts would be enough to bring the bureau back into financial security.
For organizations such the Humane Society, the country’s largest animal protection organization, anything to increase funding is a step in the right direction.
“The Humane Society of the United States was instrumental in the crafting of tougher penalties for violators of dog law and supports the funding necessary to do the work,” said Kristen Tullo, state director of the Humane Society. “We thank Sen. Judy Schwank and Rep. Pashinski for introducing legislation to help.”
Without the passage of one of these bills, the state risks a complete lack of resources to enforce dog laws across the commonwealth. The pieces of legislation are now in their respective Agriculture and Rural Affairs committees.
Logan Hullinger is an intern with the Pennsylvania Legislative Correspondents’ Association.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.