Calling it a “money grab” by the state, a loss of local control of schools and the end of quality public education, officials at a standing-room-only crowd at Fox Chapel Area High School Tuesday night said a proposal to change how Pennsylvania schools are funded is a bad idea.
The proposal in the Legislature, which would significantly reduce school property taxes while raising other levies, also got a frosty reception in Peters on Monday night.
At an emergency public meeting called by Fox Chapel District Forum, letters, phone numbers and websites were distributed so taxpayers could let their state representatives know they are opposed to legislation that would fund Pennsylvania schools by adding 1 percent to the state sales tax (as well as adding taxes to food, clothing and other goods and services) and raising the state income tax 4.95 percent, from 3.07 percent, according to the Associated Press.
The forum is an organization obligated to act in the best interests of children, said Elizabeth Klamut, president of the group. “This legislation is obviously not,” she said. “Hence the calls, emails and texts inviting you to this emergency meeting.” A vote could come as early as February or March, so parents were encouraged to contact their senators and representatives right away.
“Property tax isn’t the best way to fund the school district, but the proposal is certainly not the best solution,” said Fox Chapel Superintendent Gene Freeman. In addition, he said, the proposed legislation has never been communicated to local district superintendents or school boards.
Jamie Baxter, director of legislative policy and advocacy for the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, explained that the latest proposal hasn’t been introduced in the Senate or House yet but senators are working behind the scenes and garnering support for when they introduce it. “It’s really not in any of our best interests for this to move forward,” she said.
This is not the first time legislators have tried to pass such a law. During the last session, she said, the move ended in a tie vote with the lieutenant governor breaking the tie to defeat it. Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill County, is planning to reintroduce the bill.
School districts will lose all of their ability to govern themselves, Ms. Baxter said. Sales taxes in Allegheny County will rise to 8 percent, with increases in other taxes paid by individuals. In addition, the bill would not eliminate school property taxes. “Folks think they will get no property tax whatsoever. That’s not ture. This bill does not eliminate all property taxes.”
Mr. Freeman concurred, saying districts with any kind of debt would still have to collect property taxes to fund that debt. “This is just a money grab by the state,” he said. “I really do think this is a way to break the teachers’ union too. If they can break the districts, they can break the teachers’ union. I believe that with all my heart.”
At a meeting in Peters that included school and township officials on Monday, school board member Lisa Anderson said a fund would be created in the state government with the increased sales and income taxes and then be redistributed to districts. She said the way funding would be determined would be by looking at a district’s previous year’s tax collection, less the district’s debt service.
“There’s a lot of issues with it,” Ms. Anderson said. “That fund is not guaranteed to increase.”
The way it works now is that school districts have the ability to raise taxes to help offset rising expenses.
Additionally, Ms. Anderson said if the act passes the district would not see any additional tax money from all of the new commercial and residential developments in the township.
“Also, what if there’s a recession and personal income and sales tax goes down?” Ms. Anderson said.
“Right now, funding of schools in Pennsylvania is jointly between residents and businesses,” added township manager Paul Lauer. If the act passes, he said, “As individuals we will take on the entire burden of funding schools.”
Deana Carpenter contributed. Rita Michel, freelance writer, suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.