A man convicted as part of the so-called “Greensburg Six” who killed a mentally disabled woman will have to be resentenced after the state Supreme Court threw out his death sentence.

A new jury will be impaneled to consider whether Melvin Knight, 27, who fatally stabbed 30-year-old Jennifer Dougherty after prosecutors said he and five others tortured and abused her across three days, should be put to death.

In the majority opinion released Tuesday, state Supreme Court Justice Kevin Dougherty wrote that the jury that imposed the death sentence in August 2012 was not instructed to consider the fact that Knight had no prior convictions, something that could be considered a “mitigating factor” as the jury considered whether to sentence him to death.

Knight’s attorney told the judge that the jury should know his client had “no prior criminal history of misdemeanor or felony convictions,” but District Attorney John Peck wouldn’t agree to enter that for the record as a “mitigating circumstance.” A detective called by the defense testified about Knight’s lack of prior convictions, and the prosecutor confirmed that in his closing argument.

Advertise with us

As a result, the judge didn’t specifically instruct the jury to consider the lack of a criminal record.

“Notwithstanding the undisputed evidence and the prosecutor’s concession, the jury was not directed to find the mitigating circumstance and it ultimately did not find it proven,” Justice Dougherty wrote.

Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy wrote in a dissenting option that if both parties agree to a mitigating factor, the jury indeed must weigh it.

“However, I cannot agree that a jury is required to find a factor which has been presented for the jury’s determination absent a stipulation,” she wrote, adding that the prosecutor’s closing argument does not constitute evidence, so “any perceived ‘concession’ contained in a closing argument is not evidence the jury is bound to consider.”

The state’s highest court did not dispute the conviction itself.

Advertise with us

The prosecution said the group beat and abused Ms. Dougherty for days before Knight stabbed her to death in the bathroom. They then tied up her body with Christmas lights, stuffed it in a trash can and left it in a school parking lot.

Knight appealed his sentence in 2014, saying, among many claims, that the jury that heard the death-penalty sentencing phase of his case wasn’t properly sworn in.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.