A 29-year-old Clinton County man who claims he is at the center of a lingering mystery from Jerry Sandusky’s 2012 child-sex abuse case is set to testify for the first time today as part of the former Penn State University football coach’s bid for a new trial.
Sandusky’s lawyers believe the man is Victim 2, the boy who graduate assistant Mike McQueary saw sexually assaulted by Sandusky in a campus locker room shower in 2001. What’s more, they say, prosecutors hid him from jurors at the trial four years ago because his account didn’t match that of their star witness.
Those prosecutors say the man is an imposter who, with the help of an attorney, molded his story to position himself for the largest possible payout from Penn State.
Despite the dramatic potential at today’s hearing in a Bellefonte courtroom, Senior Judge John M. Cleland has said he has no interest in settling once and for all whether the man truly was the boy Sandusky assaulted in the shower.
Instead, the judge has directed Sandusky’s lawyers to limit their focus to what prosecutors believed at the time and if, as they assert, lead prosecutor Joseph McGettigan hid the truth and lied to jurors by telling them the identity of Victim 2 was “known only to God.”
But the prospect of his public testimony has drawn wide interest, five years after the story of Victim 2 forced a football-focused campus to re-evaluate its culture and the legacy of some of its greatest heroes.
Read More
More than any other allegation in Sandusky’s case, Mr. McQueary’s account of what he saw in that shower changed the scandal from one focused on a lone serial predator to a story about institutional failures.
It ultimately led to the firing of Penn State’s iconic football coach Joe Paterno, the still pending prosecution of three top administrators for allegedly covering up Sandusky’s crimes and the unprecedented $2.4 million fine imposed on the university Thursday by the U.S. Department of Education.
Sandusky, 72, has said he is certain the man set to testify today is the same person described in the presentment. Though the former coach is unlikely to take the witness stand, he is scheduled to appear with his lawyers at the proceeding, a continuation of an appeal hearing that began this summer. In addition to his allegations regarding Victim 2, Sandusky is seeking a new trial claiming prosecutorial misconduct and that his trial lawyers provided a woefully ineffective defense.
State investigators maintain they still don’t know the identity of the boy in the shower, but Mr. McQueary has testified several times that he reported the child’s abuse in 2001, first to Paterno and later to Tim Curley, the school’s athletic director, and vice president Gary Schultz. Neither man informed the police or child welfare authorities at the time and now face child endangerment charges along with ex-Penn State president Graham B. Spanier.
The man set to testify today was among the 32 Sandusky accusers who have received settlements from Penn State. But he has a troubled history as a potential witness, one that could impact both sides.
A former Marine, he has told investigators he met the ex-coach through Sandusky’s charity for troubled youth, The Second Mile, and soon found himself invited to Penn State football games and sleepovers at Sandusky’s house.
He grew up alongside many of the accusers who eventually testified at Sandusky’s trial. Unlike them, however, his relationship with the man extended well into adulthood. He attended the funeral of Sandusky’s mother, lived with the coach for a time while attending college and invited Jerry and Dottie Sandusky to his wedding.
When rumors began swirling in early 2011 that Sandusky was the target of a grand jury investigation, the man told state investigators the coach had never touched him inappropriately and, at Sandusky’s urging, wrote a letter of support to the Centre Daily Times.
“He has been a best friend, tutor, workout mentor and more,” the letter said. “We’ve worked together, competed together, traveled together and laughed together.”
When Sandusky was charged later that year, the man agreed to testify for the defense, telling Sandusky’s lawyers that he had been the boy in the shower, that he remembered seeing Mr. McQueary that night in 2001 — and that nothing untoward had occurred.
But within a month, the man had retained an attorney and his story changed again.
His lawyer, Andrew Shubin, testifying at a hearing this summer, said he never doubted his client was Victim 2 described in Sandusky’s presentment but felt that prosecutors were never interested in him as a witness.
“I believe that Mr. McGettigan did not want to pursue or wasn’t curious as to whether the person I believe was Victim 2 was in fact Victim 2,” he said.
Investigators say they had reasons for their doubt. Several times between February and May 2012, the man gave conflicting accounts of abuse.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.