A federal judge in Harrisburg has ordered the state prison system to release Arthur Johnson from solitary confinement, where he has spent the past 36 years.

U.S. District Judge Christopher Conner ruled Tuesday that prison concerns that Johnson might try to escape, as officials said he did in the 1970s and 1980s, are outweighed by his argument that the confinement amounts to cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Constitution’s Eighth Amendment.

“The court has no crystal ball. It may well be that Johnson will endeavor to escape again,” the judge wrote. “But Mr. Johnson is 64 years old. And he will be subject to three decades of improvements in institutional security over the general population. The Department [of Corrections] has at its disposal a broad array of investigative and penological techniques to dissuade even the most entrenched escape artist. Surely, there are less restrictive means to monitor Mr. Johnson than solitary confinement.”

Johnson’s legal team is based in Pittsburgh. It includes Jones Day partners Tom Jones and Peter Laun along with two associates at the firm, Tarah Ackerman and Mark Zheng; Bret Grote and Dustin McDaniel from the Pittsburgh-based Abolitionist Law Center; and Jules Lobel, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Mr. Grote and Mr. Lobel approached Jones Day, which handles many pro bono cases, a year ago for help in trying to get Johnson released to the general population.

Mr. Lobel said Wednesday that the ruling is not only a victory for Johnson but for all those in solitary confinement, a hot-button issue in prisons across the nation.

“I believe it is the first time that an inmate has been ordered released who was not shown to be mentally ill,” he said.

“We’re thrilled that our client is getting the relief to which he’s entitled,” said Mr. Laun.

At a hearing this summer, Johnson said he suffered from sleeplessness, anxiety, depression, obsessive behavior, anger, loss of concentration, loss of short-term memory and despair because of his years in a tiny cell.

Advertise with us

Craig Haney, a University of California psychology professor who has researched the impact of solitary confinement, said Johnson “has struggled to maintain his sanity” and has deteriorated to the point of experiencing what he called “social death.”

In granting a preliminary injunction for Johnson, Judge Conner on Tuesday gave prison officials a week to come up with a step-down plan to monitor his mental health and gradually return him to the general population.

“It is difficult to conjure up a more compelling case for reintegration to the general prison population,” the judge said. “After 36 years of isolation, Mr. Johnson deserves the opportunity to shake hands with someone other than his attorneys.”

The Department of Corrections said it is reviewing the decision.

The DOC said Johnson had tried to escape several times after being convicted of the 1970 murder of a man during a street fight in Philadelphia.

Advertise with us

But although prison officials said he remains an escape risk, they also acknowledged he had been a model prisoner for the past 25 years.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.