UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Four years after toppling a bronze statue in his likeness, Penn State University returned the late Joe Paterno to Beaver Stadium on Saturday.
But only for a few minutes.
Two short video presentations during a home game against the Temple Owls paid homage to the controversial football coach, spotlighting the players he led and other students “impacted by him.” The occasion marked 50 years since Mr. Paterno's first game as a head coach at the school.
“It's baby steps,” said Franco Harris, a former running back under Mr. Paterno and supporter of the Paterno family. He said the commemoration — which Penn State did not cast as an honor — showed the school's movement toward “not being scared to be associated with Joe.”
Thousands of fans stood and cheered the tributes, a long-anticipated but divisive acknowledgment following the school's sexual abuse scandal. The university board of trustees fired Mr. Paterno just days after the November 2011 arrest of Jerry Sandusky, a retired defensive coordinator now convicted of abusing 10 boys over 15 years.
Although Mr. Paterno was not charged, a disputed review at Penn State found that he and other university officials knew — or should have known — as early as 1998 about abuse concerns involving Sandusky. Claims revealed this summer suggest Mr. Paterno may have heard a similar complaint as far back as 1976.
He died in January 2012 at age 85, before those particular allegations emerged. His family and supporters have denied intimations of a cover-up that enabled abuse.
Still, critics of Saturday’s tributes said the public salute was premature at best. The student-run newspaper here, the Daily Collegian, editorialized against the gesture, writing that Penn State is “bigger than one person.”
“There is a cult here. I truly believe that if you can't see there are cult-ish tendencies at this school, then you're probably part” of them, said Andrew Limauro, 19, a Penn State sophomore who led an online petition against the commemoration.
Saturday morning found him outside Beaver Stadium with several handwritten signs, including one that read: “YOU FORGOT ALREADY.” He suspects Penn State planned the tributes to please financial contributors to the school, said Mr. Limauro, who attended North Allegheny High School.
Enduring a string of expletives at the stadium, he said some passers-by stopped for more thoughtful conversations. He was not pushing an anti-Paterno tirade but wanted to strengthen awareness of sexual abuse, Mr. Limauro said, arguing that the commemoration placed tributes above Sandusky's victims.
Penn State administrators did not grant interviews last week about the recognition effort, which the school timed with a halftime appearance by members of Mr. Paterno's 1966 team.
In a prepared statement, university spokesman Lawrence Lokman said the school leadership “chose to recognize Coach Paterno's significant contributions to educational excellence and generations of student athletes dedicated to making a difference.
“We understand people differ over this decision,” Mr. Lokman said. “There are hundreds of lettermen who were impacted positively by Coach Paterno, and take pride in [Saturday's] commemoration, not to mention students across the university whose Paterno Fellows scholarships make their educations possible.”
Penn State named the scholarship program for Mr. Paterno and his wife, Sue, upon its introduction in 2008. She commended the university last week for highlighting former players in its tributes.
“While we are pleased [school officials] have acknowledged Joe’s contributions, we communicated to the administration that we would like the focus for this event to remain on the players,” Mrs. Paterno said in a statement Thursday. She was not available for an interview, a spokesman said.
The Paterno family joined a group of football lettermen Friday night to host a private reunion near the football stadium, according to Mrs. Paterno’s statement. She said that gathering was to laud the contributions of Penn State football players “to the university and to society.”
“It honors the bonds of brotherhood and unity formed here and carried forward in the years since they left their alma mater,” Mrs. Paterno said.
School trustee Anthony Lubrano said she planned the Friday event to celebrate “the legacy of the ‘Grand Experiment,’” Mr. Paterno’s vision for his players to dominate both on the field and in their academics.
“There’s no question in my mind that commemorating this date in history is wholly appropriate,” Mr. Lubrano said Saturday. He said he hopes the university will soon go further and outright honor Mr. Paterno.
The school removed the coach’s statue from the east side of Beaver Stadium in July 2012, about 10 days after internal reviewers concluded that Mr. Paterno and three former executives did not protect against Sandusky and concealed crucial information about the child predator.
Those administrators — Tim Curley, Gary Schultz and Graham Spanier — are fighting criminal charges that they failed to alert authorities about Sandusky.
At the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Rape near Harrisburg, advocates declined to take a formal position on Penn State’s commemoration activities this weekend. They would rather focus on bettering the detection, prevention and reporting of sexual abuse, said chief public affairs officer Kristen Houser.
“There would be no controversy over whether [Mr. Paterno] did or didn’t do enough if he had done enough. I think everybody would be on board with that,” Ms. Houser said. “That’s not to lay blame. I think the controversy, in and of itself, speaks to the truth.”
But the full truth at Penn State — including who knew what about Sandusky, and when -— may forever remain a mystery, said John Nichols, professor emeritus and a former Faculty Senate leader at the school. He said more details could flow from unresolved court cases, among other sources.
“We, inside the university, maybe see things in a different way, but that’s what universities do: They search for the truth,” Mr. Nichols said. “We recognize we probably will never get there.”
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com. Twitter: @asmeltz.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.