The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Monday rejected a bid by two high-ranking GOP lawmakers to intervene in a legal battle over the retirement age of judges.
With no explanation, the high court denied a motion to intervene by Senate President Pro Tempore Joseph Scarnati, R-Jefferson, and Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre.
The ruling puts the two Republican leaders on the sidelines of a closely watched battle that has erupted into a forefront issue for some of the state’s top officials.
At stake is the fate of a question to voters on the November ballot that would raise the mandatory retirement age for judges from 70 to 75 — a decision that, either way, could alter the partisan makeup of the state’s highest court within the next year.
Originally intended to appear on April’s primary ballot, the now-challenged question was initially scheduled to ask voters if they would approve raising the mandatory retirement age for judges from 70 to 75.
But both Republican-controlled legislative changes contended that the wording was unwieldy and confusing. And so, they passed a measure, with the support of some Democrats, to postpone the referendum to change the wording.
Now, the new language asks only whether voters would approve of requiring judges to retire at age 75 — omitting the fact that the current mandatory retirement age is 70.
Last month, two former Supreme Court justices, Ronald D. Castille and Stephen Zappala Sr., along with Philadelphia lawyer Richard A. Sprague, sued Pennsylvania’s top election official, Pedro Cortes, to halt the change, calling it “misleadingly designed to garner ‘yes’ votes from voters who are actually in favor of restricting the terms of judges and justices.”
In a highly unusual move, the Supreme Court last week agreed to hear the case on an emergency basis.
Soon after, Mr. Scarnati and Mr. Corman, both of whom worked with top election officials to change the language, filed to intervene.
But offering no explanation other than its decision Monday, the high court denied their petition.
“I’m not going to soft sell the fact that we would obviously prefer for [intervention] to be granted,” said Drew Crompton, counsel to Pennsylvania’s Senate Republicans and chief of staff to Mr. Scarnati. “But we’re not distraught over the court’s decision because we’re not certain that their decision today is going to matter.”
But whether the wording stays as is could have significant implications, and Sen. Daylin Leach. D-Montgomery, has cast the last-minute change as little more than a political move to protect Supreme Court Justice Thomas G. Saylor, a Republican who would turn 70 at the end of this year. With Republicans currently the minority on the seven-member court — two Republicans currently sit on the court, compared with the Democrats’ five justices — keeping Justice Saylor in place could stave off another Democrat from taking a seat on the court.
Instead, Mr. Crompton said, the senators hope to participate in the case as a “friend of the court” — someone who is not a party in a suit but offers information that bears on the case.
Reached by phone Monday afternoon, Mr. Sprague said he was “very gratified” by the court’s decision.
“I think [the senators’] purpose was to make the case more complicated than it is,” Mr. Sprague said. “The action of the Supreme Court keeps the appropriate parties as opposed to the two senators.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.