HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania state workers took home $250 million in overtime pay in 2015 — a two-decade record high and a nearly 10 percent increase from 2014, a Sunday Times analysis of state payroll records found.
The $24 million increase in overtime costs continues a trend dating back at least five years as the number of state workers dropped because of hiring freezes and unfilled vacancies, creating more logged overtime. The entire state budget was $30 billion for fiscal 2015-16.
Other causes of overtime:
• Correctional officers providing round-the-clock supervision of inmates at state prisons.
• Doctors providing 24-hour patient care and medical services at state hospitals.
• State police providing security for Pope Francis’ visit to Philadelphia.
• Responses to emergencies.
The state Department of Corrections, Department of Human Services and State Police rank high with overtime costs because of their involvement with public health and safety.
Overall, 18 state departments had increased overtime costs last year compared with 2014, while 15 agencies reduced their overtime costs, said Daniel Egan, spokesman for the Office of Administration.
State officials can take some steps to offset the increasing overtime spending, said Bob Dick, a policy analyst for the Commonwealth Foundation, a market-oriented think tank. They can curb the steady increases in salaries and benefits for government employees and pursue opportunities to privatize or contract out services, he said.
State prisons
The corrections department had the biggest increase in overtime costs in 2015 — up nearly $23 million to $100 million. The department’s overtime has more than doubled since 2010 when it was $49 million.
The number of employees in the department, 14,883 in July 2015, decreased about 2.9 percent since 2010 when the department had 15,329 workers.
Meanwhile, the number of state inmates dropped about 2.7 percent since 2010, from 51,321 to 49,914 at the end of 2015.
These two trends spurred the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee this past April to study the costs of paying overtime compared to hiring new correctional officers.
“The study should give us a better understanding of why overtime costs continue to soar while the inmate population declines,” said Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill. Mr. Argall said he is concerned about the physical and mental toll overtime places on correctional officers.
Several state agencies are analyzing overtime costs at each state correctional institution to determine if hiring more correctional officers would be more cost effective than paying overtime, Mr. Egan said.
State correctional officials note that one reason for the overtime is that the department is working to fill hundreds of correctional officer vacancies stemming in part from a hiring freeze several years ago.
State hospitals
The state’s largest department, the Department of Human Services, reported $36.7 million in overtime costs last year, a $5.5 million increase.
The department had 15,700 employees in 2015.
Most of the overtime spike is tied to doctors and nurses providing care for residents at state hospitals and centers, said DHS spokeswoman Kathaleen Gillis.
“For DHS doctors, overtime pay stems from the doctors’ need to respond to calls within 20 minutes when they are on standby while on campus but off-duty,” Mr. Egan said.
Overtime costs at Torrance State Hospital in Westmoreland County, which had 193 residents at the end of 2014, caught the eye of the state auditor general.
Chronic staffing shortages at Torrance led to nearly 500,000 hours of overtime over three years. The cost to taxpayers was more than $14 million, according to an audit released in February by Auditor General Eugene DePasquale.
The audit, which covered July 2011 through November 2015, found that on average 32 employees a year worked more than 800 hours of overtime.
“The excessive overtime used at Torrance is bound to lead to a tired, overworked staff,” Mr. DePasquale said.
In response to the audit, DHS added 33 employees at Torrance while noting that other factors also contributed to the overtime there.
A portion of overall DHS overtime costs in 2015 is tied to implementation of a package of child protection laws, Ms. Gillis said.
Crime, papal visit
Pope Francis’ visit to Philadelphia in September contributed to state police overtime because troopers helped provide security. For the papal visit, state police provided 800 troopers and other personnel to assist the city and U.S. Secret Service. The overtime costs tied to the papal visit topped $700,000 and came out of the state police budget.
The department spent $27.4 million in overtime last year, which is down about $4.3 million from 2014.
In 2014, however, about $7 million in 2014 overtime was because of the 48-day manhunt in Monroe and Pike counties for accused cop killer Eric Matthew Frein. Mr. Frein, 33, of Canadensis, is charged with first-degree murder and multiple other offenses for the Sept. 12, 2014, sniper attack outside the state police barracks in Blooming Grove that killed Cpl. Bryon K. Dickson II of Dunmore and wounded Trooper Alex T. Douglass of Olyphant. He pleaded not guilty. His trial is set for March.
A state law passed in October will help curtail state police overtime in one area. State police are no longer required to escort tractor-trailers carrying super-sized loads on state highways.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.