A Pittsburgh restaurateur found out first-hand earlier this year how powerful the influence of a Poconos-dwelling Turkish cleric is — and how deep the Turkish government's antipathy for the man runs.
Adnan Pehlivan, co-owner of Istanbul Sofra restaurant in Regent Square, took two customers to visit Turkey. Journalists who wanted to write about the visitors were prohibited from doing so because Mr. Pehlivan and his guests were residents of Pennsylvania and thus believed to be connected to Fethullah Gulen -- the Islamic leader in exile blamed by the government for last week's coup attempt and long viewed as an enemy. Mr. Pehlivan doesn't know Mr. Gulen and has no connection with his global following but found Pennsylvanians were considered suspicious merely because of where they live.
On Friday, the Turkish government stopped an attempted military coup that left 265 people dead and 1,440 wounded. The Turkish president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, has blamed Mr. Gulen for the coup and announced his intent to request his extradition from the United States. Following the coup, the Turkish government has arrested or suspended tens of thousands of people from their jobs, including teachers, judges, lawyers and many more professions.
The Turkish government said that Mr. Gulen was behind a “parallel terrorist organization,” but the United States has not found any compelling evidence against Mr. Gulen.
Nevertheless, Mr. Pehlivan, 45, said visitors from Pennsylvania are subjected to stricter background checks when entering the country. Turkish officials, he said, don’t realize that Pittsburgh is far from the Poconos, where Mr. Gulen has lived for the past 17 years, and treats the state as if it were a small town full of residents connected to him.
“I’m trying to show Pittsburgh, my client, my city I live in, what kind of culture I live in and show appreciation,” he said of the yearly trips he takes with customers to Turkey. “It just makes me feel bad because I couldn’t represent my Pittsburgh city in Turkey.”
Mr. Gulen’s relationship with the Turkish president has been particularly strained since 2013, when revelations about corruption in the government led to a scandal. Government officials believed the information came from Mr. Gulen and the Gulen movement. But the hostility of the government goes back further. In 1999, Mr. Gulen chose to stay in America after traveling to the states for medical treatment because he said feared he would get arrested or killed in Turkey, He was offered refuge in a Poconos retreat owned by the Turkish community. Since then, he has lived at the Golden Generation Worship and Retreat Center in the Poconos, which is used as a place for families to vacation and a summer camp for children, according to Sait Onal, president of the Turkish Cultural Center of Pennsylvania.
Although he has remained in Pennsylvania for 17 years, Mr. Gulen has supporters around the world, including in Turkey, who follow his teachings that encourage dialogue and education as the way to eliminate poverty and conflict. Mr. Onal calls him the “Ghandi for Turkish people.”
Not everyone, though, sees Mr. Gulen as a sacred force and some people, including some in Pittsburgh, see the Gulen movement as a hoax to get more power.
“They see it as too much power in the hands of one person, too much influence on education...[Opponents to the movement] will say its all a ruse, he wants to take over when the time is right and is hiding behind this moderate Islam,” said Ronald Linden, a professor in the political science department at the University of Pittsburgh.
According to the Gulen Institute, his influence began in the 1960s when he modernized Islamic traditions with a question-and-answer series at local mosques and systematic presentation of topics over several sermons. To spread his message, several private schools have been opened in Turkey and around the world. His followers created the Gulen movement, also called Hizmet, which means “voluntary service” in Turkish.
“He’s got a fiercely loyal following. This is a highly organized network of people who are deeply committed to the cause, and the system itself is one that nurtures new followers,” said Jonathan Schanzer, vice president for research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. “He still produces statements. He’s got an infrastructure that’s operating and it will operate when he’s gone.”
His opposition is just as fierce as his followers, though, and some restaurants and mosques will not allow supporters of the Gulen movement inside, according to Mr. Onal. He said the Turkish government is using Mr. Gulen as a “scapegoat” and justifies the firing of thousands of officials, judges and those involved with academia, because they were taught in schools that support the Gulen movement.
“Mr. Gulen is a very small part of this whole but he’s being used a scapegoat unfortunately. It’s a story they are able to tell,” Mr. Onal said. “These people they are firing and jailing now, they are from all parts of life. There’s no way these people can be labeled as guleniths.”
Mr. Linden said that Mr. Gulen’s large following probably threatened Mr. Erdogan, and therefore, he blamed the Gulen movement for several conspiracies.
In Pennsylvania, two charter schools came under fire for their potential involvement with the Gulen movement. In 2011, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported that there were allegations that the Young Scholars of Western Pennsylvania and the Young Scholars of Central Pennsylvania charter schools pushed Turkish traditions and language on the students and were involved in an FBI investigation. Both schools denied any connection to other Turkish-led private schools.
Regardless of his mark on education in the state, Mr. Schanzer said he suspects most Pennsylvania residents are not aware that he is living here, or that this is a source of controversy in Turkey. Nevertheless, hundreds of protesters from neighboring states have appeared at the retreat in the past few days, demanding Mr. Gulen go back to Turkey and face justice, Mr. Schanzer said.
Mr. Gulen has stood by his statement that he was not involved with the coup and said if an international committee determined he was guilty, he would return to Turkey voluntarily. Although the process will take some time, Mr. Schanzer expects that the Turkish government will seek the death penalty. Yet, the Gulen movement has lived on while Mr. Gulen himself has been in self-imposed exile, and Mr. Schanzer does not expect it will end with him.
“The [Turkish government] is going to go after the known Gulenists, but at the end of the day, when you’re trying to kill an idea, it’s an uphill battle,” he said.
The Associated Press and the New York Times contributed. Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1130.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.