HARRISBURG — For another year at least, cigar smokers can puff away tax-free.
In the state budget deal signed Wednesday by Gov. Tom Wolf, they escaped the fate of cigarette smokers, who will have to cough up an extra $1 tax per pack. Users of snuff and chew or loose tobacco will pay 55 cents more per ounce. The price of switching to vapor products and electronic cigarettes will include a new 40 percent wholesale tax.
Just about everybody with a nicotine habit will be helping narrow the gap between money coming into state coffers and money going out. Everybody but stogie lovers.
Cigars will remain tax-free because they are the mainstay of a thriving industry in Pennsylvania. Legislators say they want to keep it that way.
“You have an industry that has been built here because of Pennsylvania’s treatment of cigars,” Sen. Pat Browne, R- Lehigh, chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, said this week. “And that is the wholesale distribution of cigars. If you decide to move against that, you are essentially destroying a partnership that will encourage that business to vacate, to leave. And they would go to Florida.”
Florida and Pennsylvania are the only states that do not tax cigars, whether the premium or the gas-station variety. New Hampshire exempts only premium types from taxes.
Mr. Browne estimated that the cigar industry in this state provides upward of 1,000 jobs.
In King of Prussia, John Middleton Co., a subsidiary of Altria, manufactures such popular machine-made cigars as Black & Milds, as well as pipe tobacco. In Lancaster County, John Hay Cigars has made hand-rolled premium cigars from leaves grown in Pennsylvania since 1882. The state also has Holt’s Cigar Co. in Philadelphia, creator of the Ashton brand; Cigars International in the Bethlehem area; and the Famous Smoke Shop in Easton, an online cigar store.
Altria’s website boasts that its Black & Mild brand is “the second-largest selling large machine-made cigar in the U.S.” In 2015, its total retail share was 27.7 percent.
Those numbers, legislators say, translate into jobs for Pennsylvania residents. Altria, for instance, employs about 480 Pennsylvanians, “more than 400” of whom clock in at the John Middleton Co. plant in Montgomery County, according to a company spokesman. Cigars International has more than 250 employees, according to its website.
“We certainly didn’t want to jeopardize the folks that work in that industry,” said Rep. Bill Adolph, R-Delaware, chairman of the Appropriations Committee. “The cigar industry is kind of homegrown, and we would like to keep it here.”
The revenue that would be generated from taxing stogies — by Mr. Browne’s estimate, $28 million annually — is “relatively modest,” compared to the job losses should companies vacate.
That explanation doesn’t pass muster with Eric Epstine.
“The industry is not going anywhere,” said Mr. Epstein, coordinator of rockthecapital.com, a political watchdog site.
Other states with large tobacco industries, he noted, still tax cigars. That Pennsylvania doesn’t is the result of “a very aggressive and well-financed lobbying campaign,” he said.
Tobacco interests drop big money in Harrisburg. Since 2014, Altria has spent more than $1.8 million on lobbying. In that same period, 34 lobbyists from four firms have promoted their clients’ interests in the Capitol.
In 2015, Altria, which also manufactures top cigarette and chewing tobacco brands, spent just shy of $1 million on political contributions and related expenses, according to the Department of State, which oversees elections and campaign finance reports.
Another cigar-affiliated political action committee, “Keep Jobs in the USA,” has received contributions from Cigars International, Famous and Holt’s executives, among others, and reported spending more than $100,000 since 2014 on political contributions and other expenses.
Ron Kaufman owns a vape shop in Willow Grove. He called the new 40 percent tax on vapor and e-cigarette products a “business crusher” that will most likely lead to the demise of his and others’ small businesses.
He pointed out that cigars contain tobacco while vaporizers do not and the latter sometimes help customers end their tobacco usage.
The presence of the tobacco industry and its lobbyists in the Capitol, definitely influenced the exemption of cigars in the revenue package, said Steve Miskin, spokesman for the House Republicans.
“When you do have a manufacturing base … large employers, members listen,” he said.
Some in the Capitol have privately grumbled that cigars were spared in part because many legislators like to smoke them.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.