Everyone, it seems, wants to get Kathleen Kane out of the Attorney General’s office. Even as a state Senate committee began debating her removal Tuesday, yet another Democrat, Montgomery County Commissioner Josh Shapiro, formally joined the race to replace her.
“I really feel called to this challenge,” Mr. Shapiro said. “The stakes are so high, and I believe I have the background and the skill set to make a real difference.”
The 42-year-old’s qualifications include a six-year stint in the state Legislature, where he helped make a name for himself by pressing for ethics reforms. In 2011, he was elected a commissioner of Montgomery County, the state’s third-largest and a neighbor to Philadelphia. There, Mr. Shapiro said, he gained experience “cleaning up messes,” stemming from criminal charges involving his predecessor.
Those charges were later expunged, but “we had a workforce where morale was low, and a fiscal situation that was a total mess,” Mr. Shapiro recalled. “I came in and conducted myself with integrity, and put in place the staff and systems to meet our obligations, and we turned it around.” He convincingly won re-election last year.
The attorney general’s race is already crowded. A spokesman for Ms. Kane recently signaled her desire to seek re-election, and she has four other Democratic challengers: Pittsburgh attorney Dave Fawcett, Northampton County District Attorney John Morganelli, Delaware County prosecutor Jack Stollsteimer and Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr. Republican state Sen. John Rafferty, also of Montgomery, is running as well.
Mark Nevins, a political consultant who has run a number of statewide races, said Mr. Shapiro “probably begins the race as the front-runner,” because “southeast Pennsylvania is where there are the most votes. And he’s a proven fundraiser.” Mr. Shapiro’s last campaign finance report, from late November, shows him with $1.4 million in the bank.
Still, Mr. Nevins said, “The Zappala name is well-known, and people in Western Pennsylvania like to support folks from their own backyard.”
Another factor: Mr. Shapiro’s resume does not include prosecutorial experience. In a statement Tuesday, the Zappala campaign said the contest “is going to be career politician vs. career prosecutor. We look forward to that debate.”
Mr. Shapiro, who has a law degree from Georgetown University, said he’d have “the best possible staff” to help advise him on criminal matters. He also chairs the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency, which studies criminal justice policies.
But viewing the office solely through a prosecutor’s lens, he added, “shortchanges Pennsylvanians. It doesn’t show the office to its full potential.”
For example, Mr. Shapiro said he would increase scrutiny of large nonprofits. “I’m not saying any of them are bad actors, but we have the ability to oversee nonprofits that are large and significant players” including UPMC and Highmark. He also pledged to closely monitor natural gas drilling practices, because “It’s up to the attorney general to make sure our environment is protected.”
Although Pennsylvania attorney generals have typically had prosecutorial experience, it’s not uncommon for other states to elect attorneys general without it.
Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor, said lacking such experience “wouldn’t immediately disqualify [a candidate] for me. … A person who’d been a prosecutor all their life might have a narrow view of things.” Still, he said, “If a person has not had any experience in a criminal justice system, people will legitimately wonder about that. What have your experiences taught you about the justice system, and where resources need to be placed?”
Then again, Mr. Nevins said, “In 2012, Kathleen Kane’s argument was, ‘I’m a prosecutor.’ Voters bought it, and it didn’t work out.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.