Former Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin says the criminal case against her was an “unprecedented and constitutionally invalid” effort by the district attorney’s office to prosecute her for violating non-criminal work regulations.
In a petition filed over the weekend, Melvin asked a federal judge to throw out her conviction on public corruption charges in a case in which District Attorney Stephen Zappala’s office said she used her staff to do political work.
In the 88-page appeal, she said the district attorney violated her constitutional right to due process in prosecuting her and that the judge in her case, Lester Nauhaus, violated her Fifth Amendment rights by making her write apology letters as part of her sentence.
Melvin said the DA violated federal law by attempting to “criminalize” work rule regulations established by the Supreme Court that bar court-appointed staffers from political activity.
Mike Manko, spokesman for the DA, said by email that “the issue being raised was previously litigated during trial and found to be without merit and as such continues to be without merit.”
Melvin also said the state courts that heard her case and her previous appeals violated the law in refusing to dismiss the “unconstitutional” charges and not allowing her a hearing to challenge the seizure of evidence from her personal email account.
Read More
In addition, she said it was an “error of a federal constitutional magnitude” for Judge Nauhaus to force her to write apologies to the state’s judges. In her federal appeal, she said the apology violated her right to be protected against self-incrimination.
Melvin was convicted in 2013 of theft of services, conspiracy and misapplication of government property. She was sentenced to three years of house arrest and two years of probation. The sentence also included a mandate to work in a soup kitchen and pay $128,000 in restitution.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.