BELLEFONTE, Pa. — Nearly two hours worth of arguments left Judge John Leete with many decisions to make as he aims to move forward the lawsuit filed by the family of former Penn State University football coach Joe Paterno against the NCAA.
Judge Leete, a senior judge from Potter County, started and finished by recommending that the parties create and submit a schedule to him in the next 30 days in an effort to move forward and “agree on something.”
“Everyone seems to accuse someone else of something in this case,” the judge said during the hearing in Centre County Common Pleas Court. Among the arguments was whether nearly 120 sets of notes and four 3-inch binders worth of emails between trustees, university lawyers and others should be kept confidential.
The NCAA’s request for former Penn State assistant football coaches Jay Paterno and William Kenney to produce additional documents came into question too, with the defense saying they’re seeking three primary documents from Jay Paterno.
These include drafts of his book “Paterno Legacy,” which is a memoir about his father, who died in January 2012. The defense also requested poll data from Jay Paterno’s 2014 run for the Democratic nomination for lieutenant governor as well as documents from his correspondence with public relations specialist Dan McGinn.
The NCAA’s lawyers said poll data from Jay Paterno’s 2014 campaign could be used to prove that his attempt to run for office was made because of his last name, not in spite of it.
The family of Joe Paterno and other plaintiffs filed the lawsuit in May 2013, accusing the NCAA of intentionally defaming and commercially disparaging them through the imposition of sanctions against Penn State.
The plaintiff’s counsel said Jay Paterno has cooperated and doesn’t have any poll data from his 2014 run. They also argued that the Paterno memoir is irrelevant in this case, though the defense pointed to the first chapter, titled “The elephant in the room,” as reason to request drafts of the book, specifically sections that mentioned Jerry Sandusky and the Freeh report.
Paterno family lawyer Patricia Maher called the defense’s request for such documents a “fishing expedition” and a “sideshow.”
Judge Leete must also figure out what to do with interviews that were conducted with Penn State employees and others who were urged to cooperate in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal. The interviews were conducted by former FBI director Louis Freeh’s team and making them public raises concerns, university lawyer Donna Doblick said.
The 2,000 pages were mistakenly turned over by Penn State and while they want them back, the plaintiffs said their concerns aren’t grounds for trying to “claw back” the documents.
Ms. Doblick said the interviewees were urged to come forward and be open and honest. She argued that many of these notes contain pages of information irrelevant to the case and that raises privacy concerns for those who cooperated with the interviews.
Among the topics she deemed irrelevant from the documents she said she sorted through were emails between trustees about whether they should attend Joe Paterno’s memorial service.
“There are 12 inches worth of documents that have no relevance to the case,” Ms. Doblick said.
Named as defendants were the NCAA; its president, Mark Emmert; and the organization’s former executive committee chairman, Ed Ray. The plaintiffs seek a permanent injunction preventing the NCAA from further enforcing the sanctions, a declaration that the NCAA’s actions and the consent decree it entered into with the university were unfair, and compensatory and punitive damages.
The NCAA sanctions stem from the child sexual abuse case of Sandusky, the former assistant football coach. Joe Paterno and university president Graham Spanier were fired in November 2011 after charges were brought against Sandusky and questions arose about how the university handled a past allegation against Sandusky.
Audrey Snyder: asnyder@post-gazette.com and Twitter @audsnyder4.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.