Prison administrators and inmate advocates agreed last week on one facet of the debate on solitary confinement: Prisons need to be more careful about putting people in “the hole.”

On Tuesday, California agreed to end its unlimited isolation of certain prisoners, including setting limits on the practice, which will result in hundreds being moved back into the general prison population. Jules Lobel, a University of Pittsburgh law school professor who is also president of the New York City-based Center for Constitutional Rights, was the lead attorney for inmates in their lawsuit against the country’s largest prison system.

Yale Law School and the Association of State Correctional Administrators, which includes the Federal Bureau of Prisons and leaders of state corrections agencies, released a study Wednesday measuring the use of prolonged isolation in the U.S. In a statement, the group called it a “grave problem” that should be limited or even ended.

“I think this is unprecedented in that you have the corrections field open up the books and look at segregation and say, ‘Look we need to do better,’ ” said John Wetzel, Pennsylvania’s Department of Corrections secretary, who is also on the ASCA’s executive committee.

Advertise with us

“I can’t think of another time in our field where the leaders of the largest organization in … corrections are leading an effort to scrutinize themselves.”

According to the study, more than 1.5 million people are incarcerated in state prisons. Among them were 66,000 prisoners who were in some type of “restricted housing” at state facilities, which hold about 73 percent of all those imprisoned in the U.S. In all, possibly up to 100,000 total prisoners were in segregation last year alone, according to the study.

To corrections officials, solitary assignments are needed to contain prisoners who may harm others. To inmate rights advocates, solitary confinement is a violation of human rights — defensible only for limited times with clear rules for a return to general population

In 2010, nearly 2,200 of Pennsylvania’s roughly 51,000 state inmates were in solitary confinement, Mr. Wetzel said. A few weeks ago, that number was around 1,970 with fewer than 50,500 prisoners, he said.

The State Correctional Institution Greene, according to the study, was one of two facilities reporting the largest percentages of prisoners held in long-term segregation, with 123 out of 271 in that assignment for more than three continuous years. Mr. Wetzel noted that most of the inmates in such housing at the Fayette County prison are on death row.

Advertise with us

Some improvements aimed at a specific prison population are already underway in Pennsylvania.

In a lawsuit settlement released in January, state prisons by mid-2016 must stop punishing seriously mentally ill inmates with assignments to Restricted Housing Units, sometimes called “the hole,” under its agreement with the nonprofit Disability Rights Network. Even inmates without mental health disorders are now entitled to psychological evaluations if they are kept in the hole for a year.

Under the agreement, when any of the 8,000 inmates with serious mental illness break prison rules, they may go instead to Diversionary Treatment Units, where they will get treatment and a minimum of 20 hours per week outside the cell. In solitary confinement, prisoners usually spend only five hours per week out of cells.

A separate partnership with the nonprofit Vera Institute of Justice to study Pennsylvania prisons’ use of solitary confinement for the overall inmate population revealed one practice that Mr. Wetzel said already has been changed. When an inmate was temporarily transferred to another facility to await a court date there, for example, he went to solitary at that facility, whether that was his regular placement or not.

“The question is why and the answer is, ‘Because it’s what we've always done.’ … For that to be our default doesn't make sense,” Mr. Wetzel said.

Advertise with us

In a speech this summer, President Barack Obama called for a review of the “overuse” of solitary confinement in federal prisons, citing science that “shows that an environment like that is often more likely to make inmates more alienated, more hostile, more violent.”

“Even if doesn't drive them totally mad, it has a profound effect on their personality and well-being,” Mr. Lobel said. “When we look back 50 years from now at this practice, I think people will say, ‘How could people have been so blind not to recognize [its] inhumanity and [its] cruelty?’ ”

Richard Dale Thomas, 30, of Vanderbilt, Fayette County, has spent much time in Restricted Housing Units since his convictions for burglary and harassment. Now at SCI Somerset, he recently wrote to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that he believes his accumulated “hole time” now runs into November.

“When I can’t go to the yard or shower or law library for 7 days, it makes me snap out and get more misconducts, then they restart the restricted movement all over again,” he wrote. “I would get fed up with being locked down all day and I would snap out again and distroy [sic] another cell and they would restart the 7-day restriction over again, and on top of that I would get more hole time added on. … Being locked up in the hole for so long really got me screwed up in the head.”

ASCA and Yale will gather more data on solitary assignments at prisons this fall, the association’s co-executive director, George Camp, said.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter molly_born. Rich Lord contributed.