HARRISBURG — The yearslong legal saga of three former Penn State University administrators accused of hiding Jerry Sandusky’s crimes moved to state Superior Court on Tuesday, where attorneys for the three men said the case against them should be thrown out.
Former university president Graham Spanier, former athletic director Tim Curley and former vice president Gary Schultz are accused of perjury, endangering the welfare of children, obstructing justice, conspiracy and failure to report suspected child abuse in the case of the former assistant football coach.
Sandusky was found guilty in 2012 of 45 counts of child sex abuse and is serving a prison sentence of 30 to 60 years.
Yet years after charges were first filed against two of the former administrators, the case lingers, largely because of continuing hearings and legal back-and-forth over the role of former Penn State general counsel Cynthia Baldwin.
Attorneys for the defendants say they believed Ms. Baldwin was acting as their attorney during 2011 appearances before a grand jury. If she was not acting as their attorney, they say, they were denied the right to counsel, and if she was acting as their attorney then she violated attorney-client privilege by later giving information to the attorney general’s office.
Much of the discussion in court Tuesday centered around whether an attorney can adequately simultaneously represent an institution and also its employees, and the importance of attorney-client privilege — the principle that what a person tells their attorney can remain confidential.
Read More
Caroline Roberto, speaking on behalf of Mr. Curley, said having counsel during a grand jury appearance is critical “so the lawyer can assist in letting the client know what would be incriminating. A lay person doesn’t know what might be incriminating.”
Similarly, Jeffrey Wall, an attorney for Mr. Spanier said, “he had no one at his arm and by his side” to help him navigate answering questions before a grand jury, as Ms. Baldwin was representing the institution of Penn State, and not Mr. Spanier as an individual.
Amy Zapp, chief deputy attorney general, argued before a three-judge panel that the men were properly advised that Ms. Baldwin was representing the university, and also representing the men in their capacity as university administrators.
“He received the representation he was entitled to,” Ms. Zapp said, referring to Mr. Schultz, rebutting a statement by his attorney.
Judge Mary Jane Bowes repeatedly questioned Ms. Zapp, seemingly unconvinced.
If an attorney were to suddenly stop representing someone in the middle of a grand jury appearance, “he is left adrift, without personal representation,” the judge said.
Todd Hoover, Dauphin County common pleas judge, ruled earlier this year that Ms. Baldwin was representing the three and their right to counsel was not denied. Tuesday’s arguments were to appeal Judge Hoover’s decision. There was no decision issued Tuesday.
Kate Giammarise: 1-717-787-4254 or kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @KateGiammarise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.