When same-sex marriage became legal in Pennsylvania on May 20, 2014, it stunned experienced political pundits and LGBT advocates who had predicted such a cultural shift wouldn’t happen for years — but when it did, the economic benefits would flow.

One year later, the benefits are flowing, but in a steady trickle, not a flood — ripples felt in the small, daily transactions of married life rather than a giant swell in tax revenue, tourism or big, expensive weddings.

“There’s a settling that takes place,” said District Judge Hugh McGough, who estimates he’s married 160 same-sex couples since U.S. District Judge John E. Jones III overturned the state’s Defense of Marriage Act, which since 1996 had defined marriage as being between a man and a woman. “It’s an unexpected thing for many couples. There’s a calmness that comes with being settled as a married couple.”

In October, Judge McGough married Diana Polson and Dawn Plummer, who were among 23 plaintiffs in the case that was filed in July 2013. The Point Breeze couple, who have been together 15 years and have two children, had already had a commitment ceremony in 2007. Now Ms. Polson can be on Ms. Plummer’s health insurance without being taxed, and, as joint filers, check the "married" box on their tax returns, which is saving them money.

Advertise with us

But their new legal status feels a bit after-the-fact.

“Honestly, life hasn’t changed. We still take the kids to school and day care. We still go to work every day. We didn’t win any legitimacy from anyone except the Internal Revenue Service,” said Ms. Plummer, sitting with Ms. Polson on their front porch while their two children, Elijah, 6, and Jude, 2½, skittered in and out the front door.

“What you have to understand, in many cases, [legal same-sex marriage] is actually being treated as a non-event,” said Kathleen Schneider, a Regent Square lawyer and LGBT activist. “These folks who thought they wouldn’t ever be able to be married, treated themselves as being married. They already had joint financial accounts, they owned real estate jointly, named one another as beneficiaries in 401(k) plans and their wills. They did as much as they could within the confines of the law.”

There are other advantages, she said. Married persons may receive spousal survivorship benefits from Social Security, to be paid to the survivor at death. There's no real estate transfer tax if you are married. As a married person, there is no Pennsylvania inheritance tax, while unmarried partners must pay 15 percent tax on everything they inherit.

For federal estate taxes, applicable to larger estates, the spouse who is the “second to die” may be able to escape estate taxes on an even larger share, a benefit not available to singles. On the down side, same-sex married couples may be socked with a marriage penalty for federal income taxes, unless one in the relationship is earning considerably less.

Advertise with us

Susan and Deb Whitewood of South Fayette are one such couple: Susan works while Deb is a stay-at-home mom, and because of their vast disparity of income, they reaped a $1,500 benefit for the first time this year when they jointly filed their taxes.

As named plaintiffs in the same-sex marriage case, they joke today about how much the wedding industry in Pennsylvania might have benefited from their business in years past. The couple had their own Holy Union ceremony in 1993, at a Shadyside church. Then, when Vermont legalized civil unions in 2000, they went up there to have another ceremony. In 2013, after the Supreme Court struck down the federal Defense Against Marriage Act, they decided to marry legally in Maryland. So when Pennsylvania became a marriage equality state, they didn’t feel the need to tie an already tightly bound knot.

“Of course, we spent $4,000 on a wedding in another state that could have been in Pennsylvania,” said Susan Whitewood, who has raised three children with her spouse. The first thing she did after the decision was to put Deb Whitewood’s name on the deed to their house.

“That brought a tremendous amount of peace of mind,” she said, because Deb Whitewood wouldn’t have to pay the 15 percent estate tax on all their assets if something happened to Susan Whitewood. “There was always a worry, quietly, or not so quietly, if something tragic should happen,” that her spouse would have to confront a huge financial burden.

Those are the micro benefits to same-sex marriage, but the big picture remains unclear.

Advertise with us

“It’s early,” said Bob Witeck, a Washington, D.C.-based LGBT business consultant whose clients include Wal-Mart, American Airlines and Marriott International. “But because these laws create fewer barriers to forming relationships, you’ll start seeing an impact. Married couples tend to be homebuyers. There will be an uptick in real estate transactions and in parenting generally, with couples spending money on their kids.”

Indeed, for gay men, “you’ll be seeing more parenting.” In the past, lesbian couples were more likely to have children, including those who had been in a previous heterosexual relationship, but that is changing.

The Williams Institute, a UCLA-based think tank, predicted an economic boost of $92 million in Pennsylvania over a three-year period, while San Francisco-based Nerdwallet.com did a similar study and came up with a $69 million figure. Wedding planners, however, haven’t reported much of a surge.

“We don’t have great data on the cost of weddings over time, but that will change,” said Lee Badgett, director of the institute, which focuses on sexual orientation and gender identity law and public policy. That $92 million spending figure doesn’t even include those who cross state lines to get married, Ms. Badgett added.

Initially, there was a rush on courthouses in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, due to pent-up demand by couples who had been waiting for the law to change, said Judge McGough, who married his partner Kris Rust in 2012 in New York. “People like being married by a gay judge, or so they’ve told me,” he said, noting that couples have frequently told him they were referred to his courtroom by clerks in other counties.

Advertise with us

Since Pennsylvania borders Ohio, a non-marriage equality state, there have been a high number of residents from that state streaming into Judge McGough’s courtroom.

“Pennsylvania is now a mecca for Pittsburgh natives who now live in states that deny gay and lesbian couples the right to marry,” said Judge McGough, noting he has married Pittsburgh natives from Florida, Texas, Michigan and Ohio, who brought their partners back here to tie the knot. “I keep tissues in my courtroom, for the heartbreak of tenant disputes, truancy and criminal cases — and for the weddings.”

In Philadelphia, there are eight openly gay or lesbian Common Pleas Court judges, said Judge Daniel Anders, who estimates that he has officiated at 100 ceremonies, while the others have done their own fair share — about 400 in all, he said.

Not included in these counts are weddings conducted in religious ceremonies, although a joint study in 2014 by the wedding website TheKnot.com and Advocate.com, the LGBT website, found that same-sex couples are far less likely than straight couples to have a religious service.

This summer should see more of an uptick in formal weddings, predicts Ms. Badgett of The Williams Institute. “People like to get married in the summer, and same-sex couples aren’t any different that way.”

Advertise with us

The same-sex wedding industry “is still in its infancy,” added Jeff Guaracino, a marketing expert who oversaw a gay tourism campaign in Philadelphia nearly a decade ago. “It’s just beginning to get momentum on a larger scale as to whether you can begin, over time, to track the economic impact,” he said.

Still, hotel managers have told him that same-sex couples haven’t morphed into Bridezillas — not yet, anyway.

“They’re seeing shorter planning times, of three to six months. If my niece gets engaged, that could mean a year of dress fittings and other planning, maybe waiting that long or up to two years to get the hotel booked. In the gay and lesbian community, that’s happening much sooner,” said Mr. Guaracino. A number of factors could be at play: Same-sex couples are spending less on average ($15,849) than straight couples ($29,858), according to the Knot/Advocate study. Same-sex couples invite fewer guests compared to straight couples. Plus, as marriage equality states have increased in number, the couples who marry first tend to be older and more established in their jobs.

Case in point: Jane Feuer, 63, and Kathleen Ferraro, 64, of Squirrel Hill, moved in together in 1984. Ms. Feuer is a professor of English and Film Studies at the University of Pittsburgh, while Ms. Ferraro is a independent writer and data analyst. When Ms. Feuer, an internationally renowned film scholar, won a Fulbright to study in Germany in 2009, the two married there — Germany recognized the union — so that Ms. Ferraro could stay in the country when her tourist visa ran out. Otherwise, she might have been deported.

In September, they married at Choderwood, a beautiful property on the Allegheny River, spent $7,000, and encountered no recalcitrant wedding vendors.

Advertise with us

“Everyone was perfectly happy to take our money,” said Ms.Feuer.

While the numbers crunchers may still be waiting to track a same-sex marriage economic windfall, for those who live out their commitment to each other and their families every day the new law’s value is incalculable.

“I think one thing that happened for us and our kids, was a sense of validation and relief that our family was legally the same as everybody else,” said Deb Whitewood, “an emotional validation, a sense that we’re the same as all our friends.”

This new state of being, this “settling” into married life, mostly reveals itself in small, unexpected moments. When Diana Polson and Dawn Plummer’s son Elijah, 6, went to the doctor with Ms. Polson, she referred, in passing and out of habit, to Ms. Plummer as her partner, her son gave her a nudge.

“My son looked at me and said, ‘Mama, really?’ Your partner? You mean your wife.’ ”

Mackenzie Carpenter: mcarpenter@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1949, Twitter @MackenziePG.