After maintaining silence for more than a month, attorneys for ousted Penn State University president Graham Spanier on Wednesday blasted former FBI director Louis Freeh and the report he issued on the university's handling of the Jerry Sandusky sex abuse allegations, calling it a "blundering and indefensible indictment."
Although Mr. Spanier's lawyers said during a news conference in Philadelphia that they had no indication their client was going to be charged by the attorney general's office -- and that they don't believe "there's a scintilla of evidence that would support that" -- it appeared the vitriolic statement was a pre-emptive strike to prevent charges similar to those filed against two other administrators at the school.
A spokesman for the attorney general's office had no comment.
Speaking at his law firm, Timothy K. Lewis, a former federal district and circuit court judge representing Mr. Spanier, used harsh language against Mr. Freeh, who was appointed to the federal bench the same year as Mr. Lewis in 1991.
"Sadly, it is now apparent that Judge Freeh was not an 'independent investigator,' but a self-anointed accuser, who in his zeal to protect victims of wrongdoing from a monster, recklessly and without justification created victims of his own."
Mr. Spanier's attorneys released an 18-page critique of the Freeh report, listing what they see as the flaws it contains.
Among the claims are that the report:
• Is neither as thorough nor complete because at least four key people involved in the situation either refused to or could not be interviewed.
• Took on a prosecutorial bent instead of being the "independent" work that was commissioned.
• Leaves out significant pieces of information -- including that nearly all of the emails exchanged among university administrators before 2004 were wiped out in a technology changeover and that testimony from the Sandusky trial runs counter to the Freeh conclusions.
• Ignores the fact that law enforcement concluded there was no sexual abuse by Mr. Sandusky in 1998 and no charges were filed.
• Investigators "cherry picked" statements to support claims instead of presenting a witness' full interview and context.
In a one-sentence statement emailed to reporters Wednesday afternoon, a spokeswoman for Mr. Freeh said simply, "We stand by our report."
Mr. Lewis acknowledged that it is unusual for colleagues from the federal judiciary to speak out publicly against each other, but he felt he had no choice, saying Mr. Freeh failed.
"There is nothing 'full or complete' about the Freeh report," Mr. Lewis said, calling it "a flat-out distortion of facts so infused with bias and innuendo that it is, quite simply, unworthy of the confidence that has been placed in it, let alone the reported $6.5 million the university paid for it."
David La Torre, a spokesman for Penn State, said the university would have no comment on the Freeh report criticisms. He did add, however, that the university would not reimburse Mr. Spanier for the cost of the news conference.
"Under the university's bylaws, the university is required to indemnify Dr. Spanier for certain legal expenses," Mr. La Torre said. We do not believe that legal fees associated with today's press conference are a reimbursable expense and do not intend to pay those fees."
But trustee Anthony Lubrano said the critique squares with problems he has had all along with how the investigation was conducted. He attended the news conference and said afterward that he texted trustees chair Karen Peetz, telling her Penn State needed to back away from previous statements accepting the Freeh report findings.
"I was surprised at the tenacity with which Judge Lewis attacked another former federal judge, but I'm glad to see somebody took the gloves off," Mr. Lubrano said.
Kevin Harley, a spokesman for Gov. Tom Corbett, who is an ex-officio member of Penn State's board, declined comment.
Following the release of the report July 12, the National Collegiate Athletic Association announced its sanctions against Penn State, including a $60 million fine, a four-year ban on postseason play, the stripping of all wins from 1998 to 2011, and a five-year probationary period.
In an interview that aired Wednesday on ABC, Mr. Spanier said he wishes in hindsight he had known more about Mr. Sandusky, a former assistant football coach, and his hidden past. But the former president defended his own actions.
He said he does not believe he had a moral obligation to track down the child reported in 2001 to have been in a campus shower with Mr. Sandusky because, when told of the incident, "I didn't conjure up anything more than what I would have thought of as simple horseplay."
The critique of the report by Mr. Spanier's attorneys notes that the Freeh investigators did not interview Penn State's former outside counsel, Wendell Courtney, or the assistant district attorney who refused to press charges against Mr. Sandusky for an incident in 1998. Both refused to speak with the Freeh group.
In addition, Mr. Lewis notes that Mike McQueary, a then-graduate assistant working for the football program who witnessed an incident in the locker room showers in 2001 between Mr. Sandusky and a young boy, was not interviewed at the request of the state attorney general's office.
Nor was Jonathan Dranov questioned. A family friend and physician, he testified at Mr. Sandusky's trial that Mr. McQueary did not describe what he saw that night in the showers as anything sexual. That is consistent with testimony provided by athletic director Tim Curley and retired vice president of business and finance Gary Schultz, as well as Mr. Spanier before the grand jury last year.
The attorney general's office charged Mr. Curley and Mr. Schultz with one count each of perjury and failure to report allegations of suspected child abuse, and trial has been scheduled for Jan. 7 in Harrisburg.
During a five-hour interview with Mr. Freeh less than a week before the report was issued, Mr. Spanier "unequivocally denied that he had ever heard a report about a sexual act involving a child," Mr. Lewis said.
Mr. Sandusky was found guilty on 45 of 48 counts against him at a trial in June in Centre County.
The Freeh report included as exhibits a number of emails that investigators believe show a coverup among Penn State administrators.
In one exchange with Mr. Schultz and Mr. Curley in February 2001, Mr. Spanier agreed that the administrators would encourage Mr. Sandusky to get counseling instead of reporting his conduct to the state Department of Public Welfare.
"The only downside for us is if the message isn't heard and acted upon, and we then become vulnerable for not having reported it," Mr. Spanier wrote in the email. "The approach you outline is humane and a reasonable way to proceed."
At the news conference, reporters asked the attorneys to address that message by Mr. Spanier. Jack Riley evaded a direct answer, instead saying his client would respond later.
Although Mr. Spanier's attorneys opened the floor to questions, they took only a few before calling an abrupt end to the gathering.
Minutes after the news conference concluded, Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, or PS4RS, an alumni group, distributed a statement reiterating the group's call for the immediate resignation of Penn State's board of trustees, saying its members have failed in their stewardship of the university.
"Every criticism articulated by Judge Lewis today should have been obvious to each and every member of the Board of Trustees when -- and if -- they reviewed the Freeh Report in detail," read the statement, noting that the group plans to issue its analysis of the Freeh report next month.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.