HARRISBURG -- The Corbett administration has responded to a federal review of the new voter ID requirement in a letter suggesting the U.S. Department of Justice has overstepped its authority because of political opposition to the law.

The Department of Justice last month notified the state that it is examining whether the voter ID law discriminates against minorities. It requested extensive documentation, including databases of voters and driver licenses, to aid in that inquiry.

In a letter Friday to the Justice Department's top civil rights lawyer, General Counsel James Schultz said the state would be willing to provide the federal agency with the same information it shared with the groups who challenged the law in state court, provided the department signs a confidentiality agreement.

"You can appreciate our desire to ensure the professional handling of this confidential information, particularly here, where unlike the petitioners in the Commonwealth Court litigation, you are without authority to request or compel the production of the requested information," Mr. Schultz wrote.

Advertise with us

He wrote that the state provided "tens of thousands of non-privileged documents" to the challengers in that case, including voter identification information, but did not describe which of the requested files would be included.

In addition to the voter registration rolls, the department asked for any records supporting a claim in a press release from the governor's office that 99 percent of eligible voters have acceptable identification. Mr. Schultz wrote that such documents "fall well outside the scope" of the law cited by the Justice Department in its request.

"In light of the absence of authority for your request for information, I question whether your inquiry is truly motivated by a desire to assess compliance with federal voting rights laws, or rather is fueled by political motivation," he wrote.

The Justice Department wrote that it is examining the Pennsylvania law for compliance with the Voting Rights Act, the 1965 law that strengthened the federal government's ability to enforce the voting guarantee of the 15th Amendment. In his letter, Mr. Schultz wrote that any question about compliance with voting rights laws was answered last week when a Commonwealth Court judge found the voter ID law does not violate the Pennsylvania Constitution.

And he argued that the 2008 ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court upholding the constitutionality of an Indiana voter ID law made the Pennsylvania statute a "matter of settled law."

He pointed to a forthcoming form of identification authorized by the Department of State as one of the "additional safeguards" the state had taken to "ensure that no eligible voter will be denied a reasonable opportunity to obtain and submit the identification necessary to cast a valid vote."