A state judicial panel on Tuesday heard arguments over whether suspended Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin should continue to receive pay while she fights her criminal charges.
Justice Orie Melvin was relieved of her judicial duties on the state's top court in late May following charges alleging that her judicial staff improperly worked on her 2003 and 2009 election bids.
Her legal battle is part of a series of criminal charges filed against the Orie family. Her sister and administrative assistant, Janine Orie, was charged in April 2010, along with another sister, former state Sen. Jane Orie, of using the senator's legislative staff for campaign purposes.
Additional charges were filed against Janine Orie in December related to Justice Orie Melvin. Jane Orie went to trial in February and was convicted of ethics violations, theft of services and forgery, and was sentenced to prison.
Justice Orie Melvin's office has been shut down, but she has continued to receive her $195,000 annual salary as a Supreme Court justice.
Francis Puskas, chief deputy counsel for the state's Judicial Conduct Board, argued before President Judge Robert Curran that the felony charges against her and the employees who subsequently lost their jobs because of her suspension are sufficient reasons to suspend her pay.
"The only person still being paid by the taxpayers is Justice Orie Melvin, the person facing trial on felony charges," Mr. Puskas said.
Her attorney, William Arbuckle, responded by pointing to past cases in which justices accused of crimes continued to receive their salaries while contesting allegations. He said the judicial system would be hindered if justices feared they could face criminal charges, and in turn the loss of pay, if they anger a district attorney arguing before them.
He also was critical of the case against Justice Orie Melvin, describing the indictment as "petty and confusing" and arguing that it failed to identify illegal actions by the justice herself.
Members of the Court of Judicial Discipline recessed briefly to discuss the case, before Judge Curran returned and said a ruling will not be issued for a week or two.
Justice Orie Melvin was joined at the hearing by various family members. She declined to comment as she left the Harrisburg courtroom.
Following a separate hearing Tuesday in Pittsburgh, an Allegheny County judge said he will decide "shortly" whether Justice Orie Melvin should be tried at the same time as her sister Janine.
During argument before Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, Assistant District Attorney William Becker said the cases should be heard together because the defendants are part of the same conspiracy.
However, attorneys for both sisters argued that their clients would be prejudiced by being tried together.
James DePasquale, who represents Janine Orie, said his client has been awaiting trial for more than two years -- although she was part of a mistrial with Jane Orie when fraudulent evidence was submitted in March 2011.
"Our position, quite frankly, is enough is enough," Mr. DePasquale said. "Janine Orie has had continuance after continuance that we never moved for."
Patrick Casey, who represents Justice Orie Melvin, said proof that Janine Orie tampered with evidence will reflect poorly on his client. Mr. Becker noted that the justice is also charged with tampering with evidence in a separate instance.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.