In the wake of a U.S. Supreme Court decision that rendered mandatory life sentences for juveniles unconstitutional, lawyers for inmates serving life for crimes they committed before their 18th birthday have begun filing petitions to challenge their sentences.
Last week, the high court ruled in Miller v. Alabama that mandatory life sentences for juveniles violate the Eighth Amendment, which prohibits "cruel and unusual punishment." The high court said that courts may still levy the penalty against young people, but only after considering their background and the nature of the crime.
In Pennsylvania, an estimated 470 people are serving mandatory life sentences for crimes they committed as juveniles and several more juveniles, including 11 in Allegheny County, are awaiting trial on homicide charges.
How the case will impact the state remains unclear, but lawyers from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh have started filing appeals.
Just a day after the court rendered its decision, attorney Tom Farrell filed a post-submission letter notifying the Pennsylvania Superior Court of the high court's ruling on behalf of 22-year-old Devon Knox, who was arrested for participating in a botched carjacking on the North Side that left a man dead in 2007.
Knox, who was 17 at the time of the slaying, was convicted of second-degree murder, although in an appeal prosecutors have conceded that it was his brother who pulled the trigger while he was standing by.
Mr. Farrell, who is challenging Knox's conviction for lack of evidence, believes the Supreme Court ruling applies squarely to his client's case.
The state Superior Court put Knox's case and several others on hold pending the outcome of the Miller case.
"The way I look at it right now, any juvenile who's been sentenced to life ... [the sentence] must be reversed and vacated for resentencing," he said.
Attorney Scott Coffey filed a petition on Thursday asking the Superior Court to remand the case of 20-year-old Terrill Javon Hicks, serving life after being convicted of first-degree murder at 16, to trial court for a resentencing.
Hicks, who was charged with fatally shooting a man in Homestead in 2010 during a robbery, already had an appeal pending with the court.
Monday, two Philadelphia attorneys also filed an emergency petition for relief for 56-year-old Tyrone Long, who was accused as a 16-year-old of murdering a teenaged gang member in North Philadelphia in 1973.
He was convicted of first-degree murder, which carries a mandatory life sentence.
Richard Narvin of the Allegheny County's Office of Conflict Counsel is representing Parish Linnen, who was 16 when he was arrested for robbing and killing a Clairton woman in 2007.
He said he plans to file a notice this week that if Mr. Linnen is convicted of first- or second-degree murder, the Miller decision precludes a judge from automatically giving him a life sentence without first considering his background and the nature of the crime.
Next week, state Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, chair of the judiciary committee, plans to hold hearings to help shape legislation the state will be forced to draft to comply with the decision.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.