HARRISBURG -- When state Rep. Curt Sonney describes his northwestern Pennsylvania district, he often uncorks one thought -- vineyards full of grapes, lots and lots of them.
"My district is the Erie area, and we are grape country," he said after a House Liquor Committee meeting last week.
Mr. Sonney, a Republican, scored a victory in the committee, as it approved his House Bill 854 and sent it to the House floor for action. The measure would allow out-of-state wineries to ship their merlots, pinot grigios and other products directly to purchasers in the Keystone State.
Currently, out-of-state wineries must send a buyer's wine to a state Liquor Control Board store, where the buyer now must prove his or her age and then pick up the wine. In-state wineries can now ship directly to consumers, who normally order by phone or online.
However, a court decision said the state must treat in-state and out-of-state wineries the same, so this bill was developed.
Mr. Sonney said Pennsylvania and 16 other states are still prohibiting direct out-of-state wine shipments to consumers, and it's time to change.
"We need to move our liquor laws into the 21st century and give Pennsylvania wine consumers the same access to the marketplace that the majority of their counterparts in other states enjoy."
The inability of out-of-state wineries to ship directly to buyers "has been a concern for a number of years," Mr. Sonney said.
Another lawmaker, Rep. Scott Petri, R-Bucks, said, "I like wine enthusiasts being able to get their wine shipped directly to their homes."
The proposed law would require wineries that want to direct ship to buy a direct shipper license, which would allow an unlimited amount of wine to be shipped directly to any Pennsylvania resident who is 21 or older. Currently, in-state wineries can ship only limited amounts of certain types of wines. Under the new bill, a delivery person (such as a UPS employee) would have to confirm, at the time of delivery, that a purchaser is of legal age.
Under House Bill 854, in-state and out-of-state wineries would be able to sell and ship directly to consumers. In its original form, the bill also would have allowed out-of-state grocery stores and other wine-selling retailers to ship directly to Pennsylvania buyers, but it was amended last week to say that only the wineries can direct ship.
Pennsylvania winemakers would also be allowed to ship their products directly to consumers who live outside Pennsylvania -- assuming, of course, that the other state is one that allows such shipments.
Mr. Sonney said wineries in Erie and other areas of Pennsylvania are proud of their products and "aren't afraid of competition" with out-of-state wineries, assuming that everyone is subject to the same rules and taxes.
One of those taxes in Pennsylvania is the so-called "Johnstown flood tax," an 18 percent levy that has been imposed on wine and spirits since 1936. That's when it was enacted to help Johnstown recover from a disastrous flood -- but to the dismay of many consumers, the tax has not been repealed. The tax is one revenue source for the state Liquor Control Board, which contributes about $500 million a year to the state treasury.
Under House Bill 854, both in-state and out-of-state wineries will have to impose and collect the 18 percent tax on the wine they ship. This would be a major change for in-state wineries, which now charge the state's 6 percent sales tax but not the 18 percent tax on wine sold and shipped to consumers.
If the bill is approved, in-state and out-of-state wineries will have to charge the sales tax and the flood tax on wine that goes directly to consumers; this is likely to increase the cost of in-state wines. Mr. Sonney said in-state vintners are divided about charging the 18 percent tax, but most of them want to be able to ship directly to consumers and so must go along with the provision that all wineries be treated the same.
It's not certain when the full House will act on the direct shipment bill. Two major issues will come before it: action on the fiscal 2012-13 state budget, which must be adopted by June 30, and the controversial issue of privatization of the state-owned wine and liquor stores, which also may come up for a vote in June. The Sonney bill could be amended into the privatization bill, or may await action in the fall.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.